D.S. al Coda wird ignoriert?
Hallo,
ich kämpfe nun schon seit Tagen mit den Sprungmarken in Musescore 4.4.4.
Mein letzter Stand im angehängten Score ignoriert das D.S. al Coda im Takt 28 völlig und macht einfach im Takt 29 weiter.
Irgendeine Idee, wo ich mich hier verlaufe?
Auch in der Doku und im Forum habe ich nichts dazu gefunden. Die Beispiele aus dem Forum funktionieren bei mir alle wir erwartet. Nur halt nicht in meinem Score.
Vielen Dank!
OS: macOS 10.15, Arch.: x86_64, MuseScore Studio version (64-bit): 4.4.4-243461245, revision: 2232670
| Anhang | Größe |
|---|---|
| Mein Herz schlägt für Dich v7_6 Forum.mscz | 64.18 KB |
Comments
See if this works for you:
1-Mein Herz schlägt für Dich v7_6 Forum.mscz
Your 2. +3. volta was missing an end repeat barline at measure 17 - needed to set the Play count and also to refer playback to the start repeat barline. (Compare to measure 15.) Additionally, I put an end hook on the volta line (using the Properties panel).
Also...
I assumed you want the 1. volta at measure 32 to go back to the beginning of the Coda, so I added a start repeat barline to the Coda.
Other potential problems...
1. You show lyrics for only 3 verses. What lyrics are sung for the 4th time? (There is no 4th verse written as lyrics.)
2. The 2. +3. volta ends at measure 17 which has 4 beats. Playback then returns to the pickup measure of 1 beat which will disrupt the overall 4/4 rhythm. You may want to shorten measure 17 by 1 beat.
Compare to measure 6, measure 15, and measure 28. All have 3 beats - and return to the 1 beat pickup measure, maintaining the 4/4 rhythm.
Antwort auf See if this works for you: … von Jm6stringer
A very good analysis!
Hi, thanks alot for your analysis and proposal for fixes.
Short comment: The D.S. al Coda does work now. But all the other repeats of Verses are wrong now.
In my example it was exactly the other way round. So what was the actual fix, you've applied to the D.S. al Coda to work? I do also like, how you have seperated the Coda from the rest. How is this done?
FYI here is the intended flow of the Score
Intro
(Segno) Verse1
Verse2
Chorus
Interlude (D.S. al Coda)
Verse3
Chorus (to Coda)
(Coda) Chorus
FINE
Sorry for the confusion, I should have mentioned that already in my initial post.
With regards to your comment about Verse 4, you are right, it is not finished yet and might be removed altogether. Since I have never figured out how to return savely to that verse after the chorus after Verse 3.
So it was intended to fit in here:
...
Verse3
Chorus
Verse4
Chorus (to Coda)
(Coda) Chorus
FINE
But I could not figure out how to set this up.
With regards to your comments about the 4 bar mesures in the Voltas to be 3 bars instead. I guess it becomes clear with the intended flow mentioned above. Since the Voltas from 2-4 are all going directly to the chorus, they need to be 4 bars. Only volta 1 jumps back to the beginning of the verse2 and therefore is 3 bars only.
thx again
Antwort auf Hi, thanks alot for your… von stars-media
Just to add, the missing repeat at the end of Volta 2+3 was intentional, since it should continue from there directly to the chorus.
Missing repeat in bar 32 is a good catch. thx Although the repeat was working even without it. ;)
Antwort auf Just to add, the missing… von stars-media
So, now I have removed the Repeat in bar 17 (Volta 2+3) and changed the volta bracket back to open style and it is all working now!
Still my open question out of curiosity, how did you fix the the D.S. al coda?
I have to admit I do not see the differences, that made it suddenly work.
thx a lot!
Antwort auf So, now I have removed the… von stars-media
The volta in m. 24 has an end hook. Remove the end hook!
(However, I don't know why ...)
Antwort auf The volta in m. 24 has an… von HildeK
Yes, indeed. That fixes the D.S. al Coda jump, but now, the To Coda happens already in Bar 22, so before the voltas. Which means the chorus after verse 3 runs one bar short.
Strange...
Any other idea?
thx
Antwort auf Yes, indeed. That fixes the… von stars-media
Okay, deleting the To Coda in bar 24 and adding it again in bar 24 did fix that problem as well.
Pretty erratic behaviour overall.
Antwort auf Okay, deleting the To Coda… von stars-media
It did work only once. :( Back to bug fixing...
Antwort auf The volta in m. 24 has an… von HildeK
And in the fixed Version from jm6stringer, the endhook in bar 24 is also present. And there it works.