Copyright Technicalities
Hi! I have a question about copyright. If in our score there is a small easter egg to another published work at the end, does it still count as original work? Or is it based on another widely famous published work?
Hi! I have a question about copyright. If in our score there is a small easter egg to another published work at the end, does it still count as original work? Or is it based on another widely famous published work?
Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.
Comments
What is a small easter egg in a score? Could you provide an example?
I asked one of my local AI models this, and this was the response:
"The answer to this question is a bit nuanced, but I'll break it down for you.
In general, copyright law protects original expressions of ideas, not the ideas themselves. This means that if your score contains an Easter egg or reference to another published work (in this case), and:
1. It's transformative: The Easter egg adds something new, unique, or creative to the existing work.
2. You're using it in a way that doesn't infringe on the original creator's rights:
- You're not copying significant portions of the original work.
- Your use is for purposes like parody, criticism, education, or commentary (fair use).
3. Your score as a whole remains an original work: The Easter egg isn't so prominent that it overshadows your own creative expression.
In this case, if you've included a small Easter egg to another published work at the end of your score:
- It's likely not considered copyright infringement.
- Your score is still considered an original work because:
* You're referencing the other work in a way that doesn't copy significant portions or harm its market value.
* The reference is relatively minor and serves as a nod to another creative piece, rather than being central to your own composition.
However:
- If you've copied substantial parts of the original work (e.g., melody, harmony, or lyrics), it might be considered copyright infringement.
- If the Easter egg becomes too prominent or integral to your score's overall character, it could raise questions about whether your work is truly an original creation.
To ensure you're on safe ground:
1. Keep the reference subtle: Make sure the Easter egg doesn't overshadow your own creative expression.
2. Use fair use guidelines: Consider how your use of the other work aligns with fair use principles (parody, criticism, education, commentary).
3. Consult a copyright expert or attorney if you're unsure about specific aspects.
In summary: while including an Easter egg to another published work might not necessarily make your score non-original, it's essential to ensure that:
- The reference is transformative and doesn't infringe on the original creator's rights.
- Your score remains an original work with its own creative expression."
Consider that information with a grain of salt, much like you would a Wikipedia article. They are just guidelines. When in question, ask a copyright lawyer attorney.
In reply to I asked one of my local AI… by smittyVanilli
Just a small comment. Harmony, harmonic progression, chords that work with melody, cannot be copyrighted.
Saying that a specific chord progression works with the melody of a specific song does not infringe on the copyright of the song.
Stating that the below chord changes work with the song All of ME in Bb major does not infringe on any copyright held by the composer of "All of Me":
You need to ask a copyright lawyer in your locality, not a forum that has members from all over the world.