Notes of tablature pasted on standard stave don't match

• Aug 21, 2014 - 00:53
Type
Functional
Severity
S2 - Critical
Status
closed
Project
MuseScore

1. Open attached score (produced in 2.0).
2. Click on the bar of tablature (selecting it).
3. 'Copy'.
4. Click on rest of standard stave.
5. 'Paste'.

Expected result:

Notes of tablature pasted on standard stave don't match (Expected result).png

(The song has a key signature of D major.)

Actual result: The notes in the standard stave sound in accordance with the tablature, but the notation does not match this, or what is in the expected result - the notes are wrongly mapped:

Voice 1: E/G tie (should be A tie), B (should be F♯).
Voice 2: G throughout (should be D).

Notes of tablature pasted on standard stave don't match (Actual result).png

Using MuseScore 2.0 Nightly Build (8a0fd79) - Mac 10.7.5.

Attachment Size
Notes of tablature pasted on standard stave don't match.mscz 1.94 KB
Notes of tablature pasted on standard stave don't match (Expected result).png 148.13 KB
Notes of tablature pasted on standard stave don't match (Actual result).png 73.02 KB

Comments

• Aug 21, 2014 - 10:15

As you can see:

With the first file "Electric Guitar", the "I" dialog. displays two standard staffs. I do not know why, I don't changing anything particular in my memory (to verify)

The pasting works well, even you reset the second staff standard to a full Tab staff.

With the second file, "Electric 8aofd79", "I" display is correct. And the pasting also.

So I do not quite understand. I drop this story! But, in all cases the pasting operation works with the expected result.

Reply

• Aug 21, 2014 - 12:51

I preserve "Needs info", but there's something fishy, alas! ("anguille sous roche, hélas" in French!) I'm going to get this result, with a wrong result of the first A (-> E)
electric 2.jpg

It has probably something to do with the order in which you do the operations. For example, if you first select a simple 6-str tab, then go to advanced style properties to be able to show the rests.

Clearly, this deserves further investigation (:

So, please, chen lung, thank you to precise with details the order of all the steps you made to obtain (and reproduce) the first wrong result :)

Attachment Size
electric 2.jpg 18.16 KB

Reply

• Aug 21, 2014 - 16:38

OK.

(Nightly 3b44bc1/ Windows 7)

1) Create new score for electric guitar standard staff

2) Select Staff1 -> Add staff -> change type for Tab 6str. full -> Next (2#, 4/4, two measures) -> Finish.

So:
1GE.jpg

3) Enter the numbers in tab staff

2Ge.jpg

4) Copy - Past the tab staff measure on the standard staff measure.
Result: correct

3GE.jpg

EDIT: the wrong result in comment #7 is my fault and due on the issue always active: http://musescore.org/fr/node/25867
I had entering the A first voice (tied) with overwriting 0 (mouse) + 5 (numeric kb). In this way, it does not work (:

Attachment Size
1GE.jpg 12.93 KB
2Ge.jpg 21.08 KB
3GE.jpg 25.61 KB

Reply