Adding an additional Alto Sax that is displaying the incorrect Key Signature.
I created a Concert band score in the key of F major. I decided to add a 2nd Alto Sax player and when I do, it displays Concert C Major.
Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.
Comments
That's a transposing instrument, so perfectly normal
Use the Concert Pitch button
In reply to That's a transposing… by Jojo-Schmitz
Are you sure?
XR_Racer has a score in F-major and already a Alto Sax staff.
Adding a second Alto Sax, it should show the key D-major.
Even if pressing the Concert Pitch button, it should show either F-major or, when released, D-major keys.
The key should be the same as it is in the existing Alto Sax.
In reply to Are you sure? XR_Racer has a… by HildeK
Score needed
In reply to Are you sure? XR_Racer has a… by HildeK
Trust me, I know how it should work. That is why I posted this. I am including screen shots portions of the score with and without the added Alto Sax part both in Transposed score view and concert pitch view.
In reply to Trust me, I know how it… by XR_Racer
Sorry, score is needed
Hmm, I can't reproduce this issue on a new score:
![wrewerwer.JPG]( "wrewerwer.JPG")
In reply to Hmm, I can't reproduce this… by oMrSmith
Here is the score. I added the 2nd alto while being displayed as a Transposed score. I removed the 2nd alto part and tried again, but added the 2nd alto part while the score was displayed in Concert Pitch and the part was added correctly.
In reply to Here is the score. I added… by XR_Racer
Apply F-Major once and all seems fixed
In reply to Here is the score. I added… by XR_Racer
Ok.Musescore 4. Seems to be a bug.
I see your result also in MS 3.6.2, but when I set the signature key for the score again, it is fixed.
Try this too.
In reply to Here is the score. I added… by XR_Racer
This must be a bug, at least some kind of corruption.
In your score, this happens with other transposing instruments too
if they are - as you described - added while not in concert pitch.
In reply to Here is the score. I added… by XR_Racer
I can confirm the issue on this particular score, but not in a new one. So the question is, what is different about this score - how did it get into this state?
Regardless of the answer, it is worth opening an issue on GitHub and attaching this score (zipped).
In reply to I can confirm the issue on… by Marc Sabatella
Thanks Marc.
How would I do that?
In reply to Thanks Marc. How would I do… by XR_Racer
Use this link: https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/issues/new?assignees=&labels=&te…
In reply to Use this link: https:/… by Marc Sabatella
Done. I included the screenshots as well as steps to reproduce and the score.
In reply to Done. I included the… by XR_Racer
Thanks for https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/issues/16538, duplicate of https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/issues/15314, fixed in master (so will be in 4.1), but not in 4.0.2