Corrupted
This file is corrupted so cannot publish to musescore
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Orchestra From_THE_GREATEST_SHOWMAN_NEVER_ENOUGH.mscz | 535.94 KB |
Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.
This file is corrupted so cannot publish to musescore
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Orchestra From_THE_GREATEST_SHOWMAN_NEVER_ENOUGH.mscz | 535.94 KB |
Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.
Comments
See now: 1Orchestra From_THE_GREATEST_SHOWMAN_NEVER_ENOUGH.mscz
In reply to See now: [inline:1Orchestra… by cadiz1
Thank you very muchh !!!!
In reply to See now: [inline:1Orchestra… by cadiz1
So how did you fix the corruption?
I have reported a possible cause for this issue on github
https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/issues/26207
Sorry, but I don't understand the corruption message.
Incomplete measure: Part score: Violoncello, measure 25, staff 1. Found: 0/1. Expected: 4/4.
What is staff one of a one staff part? Just what is the problem with measure 25? Two whole notes in voice 2 and one whole note in voice 1 is not a problem.
And why did resetting the cello part fix it?
In reply to Sorry, but I don't… by bobjp
@bobjp
> Two whole notes in voice 2 and one whole note in voice 1 is not a problem.
Open Violoncello part and look at 25 measure
In reply to @bobjp > Two whole notes in… by mercuree
Yes? What am I looking for? Measure 25 looks the same in the original file and mine. Something is not right, but what?
In reply to Yes? What am I looking for?… by bobjp
Please note the red frames.
![violoncello.png]( "violoncello.png")
In reply to [inline:violoncello.png] by mercuree
Yes, I know. But neither is incorrect. And changing either one to look like the other doesn't remove the corruption. And which one does the corruption refer to. And what is a 0/1 measure. And what is staff one of a one staff part?
In reply to Yes, I know. But neither is… by bobjp
Ok, my bad. Let's compare them with the colors of voices.
![2025-01-24_00-53-47.png]( "2025-01-24_00-53-47.png")
As you can see, the voice 1 (blue color) in violoncello part is completely missing.
Voice 1 cannot be missing. It must always be present in the form of notes or rests.
Found: 0/1 probably means Musescore expects whole rest or note but doesn't see anything. I don't know why it doesn't say 0/4 in the message.
Staff 1 means the first Staff in parts.
Parts can contain multiple staves and instruments.
In reply to Ok, my bad. Let's compare… by mercuree
I've just never seen "staff 1" before.
The question is what caused this? I can't recreate it. And changing the top whole note to voice 1 fixes it.
In reply to I've just never seen "staff… by bobjp
I fixed it by adding a whole note in voice two to measure 26 and then tying the voice two whole note from measure 25 and 26 together to get this monstrosity:
![tie.jpg]( "tie.jpg")
As you can see the ties are wrong. I could fix it by flipping the middle tie, but I don't like it that way, so I'll leave it like that and risk a side eye from the performer.
UPDATE: This one looks a little better.
![tie2.jpg]( "tie2.jpg")
UPDATE AGAIN: Never mind, that doesn't fix the underlying corruption.
Never mind!
In reply to I've just never seen "staff… by bobjp
@bobjp
![2025-01-24_15-14-41.png]( "2025-01-24_15-14-41.png")
> I've just never seen "staff 1" before.
If you click on the instrument name, the staff index appears below
> And changing the top whole note to voice 1 fixes it.
Actually, no. You fix the error with voice 1 and satisfy the validator so it doesn't show the error anymore.
But the problem remains. You can verify this by deleting mp dynamic in parts. You'll find that dynamic won't be deleted in full score.
> The question is what caused this?
Without adding double/dashed/dotted... barline I can't reproduce this problem, so that's the prime suspect.
In reply to @bobjp If you click on the… by mercuree
It affects the measure in the entire score. Delete the mp in the 1+2 clarinet part (which has a voice 1 and 2 whole note) and it still shows in the score. But not if you delete the mp in the clarinet 3 part.
So while there is still some kind of problem, it doesn't keep you from being able to work on the score. These kinds of things are why I don't do anything in parts until the score is finished.
In reply to It affects the measure in… by bobjp
Cadiz fixed it apparently. Trying to get their solution now.
In reply to Cadiz fixed it apparently… by FBXOPWKDOIR2
Not entirely. Yes the score will save. I found a way to do that above. But in his score (as in mine) go to the cello part and delete the mp. then go back to the score and see that it is still there.
In reply to Not entirely. Yes the score… by bobjp
No, I deleted the mp in both versions, saved both without error messages, and reloaded both and the mp's were still deleted. Obviously there is a problem here if I can't reproduce this but it's happening on your rig. Before deleting the mp, both loaded fine without errors.
UPDATE: One thing I did change on the Cadiz version is that I made the measure numbers visible on the top most staff and at every measure. But that didn't change anything else.
From what I could gather, the problem seems to be that the double barlines (and the original work has a lot of them) are causing corruption somehow. (See the mercuree post way above )
In reply to No, I deleted the mp in both… by FBXOPWKDOIR2
"No, I deleted the mp in both versions, saved both without error messages, and reloaded both and the mp's were still deleted."
That isn't what I did.
In reply to "No, I deleted the mp in… by bobjp
OH OK I see where you say you deleted the mp in the parts but not in the score and the change was not reflected. Be right back....
In reply to "No, I deleted the mp in… by bobjp
OK. I opened the cello part, went to rehearsal C (measure 25), and deleted the mp. Then I went to the score. The mp is gone. If this is what do did, then again, there is something wrong here. Full disclousure: I made all the measure numbers visible again.
In reply to OK. I opened the cello part,… by FBXOPWKDOIR2
I don't think measure numbers have anything to do with it, as you say.
re-download the Cadiz1 score. open the cello part delete the mp in measure 25. It should still be in the score. I just did this. BTW are you loading Muse sounds or Basic.
In reply to I don't think measure… by bobjp
Your version and Cadiz version are both using Muse Sounds. I did not change any mixer settings that are loaded.
Whenever I use Musescore, due to certain unrelated problems I've been having with Muse Sounds, I no longer use them and have reverted back to MS Basic.
Whatever sounds are being used during the creation of the uploader's file, that will be reflected in the mixer.
In reply to OK. I opened the cello part,… by FBXOPWKDOIR2
@FBXOPWKDOIR
> OK. I opened the cello part, went to rehearsal C (measure 25), and deleted the mp. Then I went to the score. The mp is gone.
I can't confirm that.
In reply to @FBXOPWKDOIR > OK. I opened… by mercuree
Unfortunately, I can.
![score.jpg]( "score.jpg")
![part.jpg]( "part.jpg")
Like I said, obviously a problem.
EDIT: Also there's a weird ophaned tie or slur there on measures 31-32.