XML crashes MS 2.1 871c8ce
The file was exported by SmartScore X2 Pro.
Importing it to MuseScore crashes it every time as it imports the file.
I don't even get the "This file is corrupted" dialog box.
Any suggestions as to how I might fix it?
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Belshazzar 03, 017-031.xml | 1.61 MB |
Comments
yes, crashed.
I converted it.
See the attached document.
There's warnings about the errors.
In reply to yes, crashed… by Ziya Mete Demircan
I received no warning in 2.1 or 2.2-dev, just a crash. I looked at the file in an xml editor that usually points out errors, but it showed none. I saw nothing obvious wrong, but I don't know every legal XML command.
In reply to I received no warning in 2.1… by mike320
Crash confirmed in current 2.2-dev, SIGSEGV in Ms::MusicXMLParserPass2::notations(Ms::Note*, Ms::ChordRest*, int, Ms::MusicXmlTupletDesc&, bool&). No time for further debugging right now.
In reply to yes, crashed… by Ziya Mete Demircan
Thanks, Ziya.
The errors are numerous, yet now it opens and displays in MuseScore.
How were you able to convert the XML, while it was crashing MuseScore?
-Tom
In reply to Thanks, Ziya… by tomfeledy
At first look, I saw a Jump and a Marker that were not correct, and some extremely long Slurs.
The Errors dialog box shows errors in timing starting at Measure 9, yet I don't see them getting odd until Measure 74, where it is notated as 9/4 and finds it actually to be 91/64.
This is typical of the files I import from SmartScore X2 Pro, yet usually does not produce a repeated crash.
There must be something else causing the crashes, yet you were able to circumvent them - how?
In reply to At first look, I saw a Jump… by tomfeledy
Submitted issue #267569: [MusicXML import] crashes MS 2.1 871c8ce
In reply to Submitted issue #267569: … by Leon Vinken
Fix available, see pull request 3355.
In reply to Fix available, see pull… by Leon Vinken
Where can I find "pull request 3355?"
In reply to Where can I find "pull… by tomfeledy
Click the link to the issue report. but unless you are programmer eager to review the proposed code, it won't be very enlightening.
In reply to Where can I find "pull… by tomfeledy
Actually that PR just got merged, so the fix is in the next nightly builds, for master and 2.2
In reply to Actually that PR just git… by Jojo-Schmitz
Thanks, Jojo.
When and where can I download the next nightly build?
In reply to Thanks, Jojo… by tomfeledy
At https://musescore.org/en/download#Development-builds
Currently no up to date builds for Windows thought
In reply to At https://musescore.org/en… by Jojo-Schmitz
No problem, I use a Mac. The timestamp on your comment above is Dec. 17th and you say "next nightly builds." Not sure what time zone you are in or if that matters, but here it is still the 17th.
So when would be best to download that new build?
-Tom