Audio and Playback Issues
Fortunately I don't think I've ever had to write in this forum because this software is so well made and this forum is so helpful. However, I have looked into this issue on this forum and others and still have found no repeatable or long-term solutions.
The Problem: Seemingly at random, Musescore will stop producing audio when I click on a note. If I press play in the playback bar or panel, the play button lights up but no audio is produced and the trackhead-highlight thingy does not move.
This has occurred at random points during a session, on scores of varying lengths, with anywhere from 1 to 21 instruments, from as long as 30 or 40 minutes into a session, to as short as the beginning of the session.
On occasion, upon opening a score and immediately pressing play, the score will begin to play with a grainy, warped, poor-quality audio for the first few bars and then either proceed normally (sometimes after pausing and then resuming) or stop playing entirely (at which point the program goes into the state described above).
I may be projecting onto the issue, but I do believe that it has increased in its frequency over the past few months. As of the past two weeks I don't believe I've had a session where the issue doesn't occur at some point. This has all occurred over various updates of Musescore 3 (it never happened with 1 or 2).
Troubleshooting: I have tried changing the audio output in the preferences of Musescore. This has never worked. Most often, during the issue, there are no options available in the dropdown for input. I tried restarting my computers audio drivers as well as reinstalling them and tried different options. None of these affected the problem and my computer never was able to come up with a solution.
Current Solution: Currently I have one foolproof solution: restarting my computer. This takes a good 5 to 15 minutes and much longer if it needs to update. Thusly, it is not ideal. Sometimes restarting Musescore fixes the problem. Other times, it does not.
Musescore or Computer: After research it appeared to me that it was a problem with my audio drivers (hence why I tried reinstalling and restarting them). I'm still not sure if that's the case, since I can always get other programs to make sound when Musescore will not. About 3 or 4 times over the past several months (since the problem began), I've experienced similar issues with two other programs (a computer game and Youtube through Google Chrome). However, their rarity compared to Musescore's constant dysfunction leads me to believe that if they are connected, it is loosely, and that Musescore is presenting its own self-contained problem. I've also considered that it could be a problem with my computer that the particular program of Musescore agitates.
I am a composition major at college and compose and arrange for a regularly gigging band. Despite my peers and professors urging me to use Finale, I still persist in my appreciation and belief in Musescore (and what it stands for), and thusly, it is the only program I use for my studies and work. This issue has me at my wits end. It makes composing without a piano (something I have to do on a regular basis) difficult and cumbersome, and less desirable. I need to find some sort of solution quickly because it is eroding away ever so slowly at my work and education.
I know this is a long-winded and wide problem, and I don't know much about computers, so if this is not a proper forum for this problem I apologize. Any help I can get is greatly appreciated. Please let me know what files or pictures I should upload if any.
Comments
If you haven't already done so, you could try:
https://musescore.org/en/handbook/3/revert-factory-settings
Change the SoundFont
Switch to Page View
Which version do you use on which operating system?
Attach here a score you are having problems with.
In reply to If you haven't already done… by Shoichi
Thanks for the quick reply!
Sorry for not giving detailed system information! Currently I'm using version 3.0.5.5992 (the most up-to-date?) on Windows 10, but this has occurred since January, and I've gone through several different Muescore updates throughout that period. The problem, if anything, has gotten worse.
I believe changing the Soundfont was the process I tried to detail doing in my original post, but I will look that up again to make sure. Switching to Page View is an interesting one, but I switch back and forth between continuous and page view throughout my work, and the problem has appeared in both views.
Although I have a good number of customized settings, I will begrudgingly try resetting to factory settings, as it seems like one of the only things I haven't tried, and I know that can solve a lot of strange little problems.
As for scores, this issue has occurred with just about every score I've touched since January. So I'm not sure that will help. I will still attach a couple different scores with various lengths, instrument numbers, etc. which have shown the problem recently, just in case it's some sort of virus being carried by my scores? I'm not a computer person, but that seems unlikely.
Thanks again!
In reply to Thanks for the quick reply! … by Texadon the Bl…
Don't rush to use revert-factory-settings. Try using a Nightly https://ftp.osuosl.org/pub/musescore-nightlies/windows/
I'll listen to your attachments, but be patient and there'll be a better answer.
In reply to Don't rush to use revert… by Shoichi
Alright, thank you. I'll definitely watch this thread for any other potential solutions.
In reply to Alright, thank you. I'll… by Texadon the Bl…
you can avoid reverting to factory settings by simply downloading and installing a replacement SoundFont. Make sure to apply the "Set as Default" button in the Synthesizer after loading the replacement SoundFont
https://musescore.org/en/node/96811
Christine (made with 2.1) It seems to sound good here on Mint (32 bit) with the default sounfont. (why an extra stave for the right hand?)
My Lucky from measure 45, Tenor 2: Sound disabled by Inspector?
In reply to you can avoid reverting to… by Shoichi
On this old pc I don't notice the problems you say. It is not a powerful machine and if I change the notes or step from Continuous View to Page View it will be slightly delayed in the answer (My Lucky).
Other comments from contributors?
In reply to On this old pc I don't… by Shoichi
Yes, I'm fairly certain the problem isn't with the scores but with my system/programs.
(As to the two notational notices- that notation in Gecko is an indication of the rhythms at which the changes are occurring for the soloist, and is intentionally not sounding. In Christine, this is a rarer form of notation for lead sheets in which a specific bass line is intrinsic to the piece. Note also that the harmonies played by the horns are included, not just the melody, and that for clarity I even spread that across a grand staff.)
In reply to Yes, I'm fairly certain the… by Texadon the Bl…
Did you also try what was said in the link above?
go into your soundcard configuration from Control Panel and ensure that the "Allow applications to take exclusive control of this device" in the Advanced tab of both Playback and Recording is unticked.