[1.0] Lyrics limits effectiveness of Staff Distance
I know there are posts related to this point, but I could not find one which addresses this specific aspect.
Setup: MuseScore 1.0 rev. 4140 (self-compiled under Win XP, Qt SDK 2010-02, Qt lib 4.6.2), but the same thing applies to released 1.0 too (it possibly also applies to trunk, but I have not run specific tests).
Steps:: Loads the attached sample scores.
All scores contains 10 voices with just one note and a lyric syllable each. The difference between them is only the "Style | Edit General Style... | Page | Staff Distance" parameter: namely 10.5sp, 10.4sp, 10.3sp, 0.0sp. All other parameters use default values.
Result: Down to 10.4sp the distance between staves decreases (the 10.4 example is slightly smaller than the 10.5 example). But, below 10.4sp, the staff distance does NOT decrease anymore: the 0.0sp example is tall exactly the same as the 10.4 example.
An image is also attached showing a direct comparison between the scores.
Expected result: it should be possible to reduce the actual staff distance to whatever value the user needs / thinks appropriate.
Very small values might make little sense in most occasions, but the user is ultimately responsible for the format/layout and the program should not "take over" and force a layout.
Notes:
1) Without any lyrics, the staff distance can be effectively reduced down to 0, having the staves touching each other. So, the issue is a consequence of the lyrics.
2) Taking into account the default values of 2sp for lyrics top and bottom margin, this means that the lyrics itself is taking up 6.4sp (10.4 - 2 - 2), i.e. the sole presence of the lyrics takes away, vertically, more than one time and a half of staff height (normal staff is 4sp high by definition).
This is way too much and much more than the actual height of the lyrics text.
Attachment | Size |
---|---|
TestStaffDistance_10_5.mscx | 32.92 KB |
TestStaffDistance_10_4.mscx | 32.92 KB |
TestStaffDistance_10_3.mscx | 32.92 KB |
TestStaffDistance_0.mscx | 32.92 KB |
TestStaffDistance.png | 50.08 KB |
Comments
I didn't dig the bug report yet, but are you aware of Lyrics top and bottom margins ? in style -> Page
In reply to I didn't dig the bug report by [DELETED] 5
In fact, I quote them in the above report.
Reducing both those margins to 0.0, still leaves the minimum actual staff distance to 6.4sp (exactly as predicted above): any lower value in the "Staff distance" style parameter has no effect.
Thanks,
M.
Trunk has the same issue, albeit a little smaller:
By reducing the lyrics top and bottom margins to 0.0, the minimum effective staff distance is 4.0sp: any value in "Staff distance" lower than 4.0sp has no effect.
M.