Tuple can't cross barline
For an example of the problem I'm having under particular circumstances, if I want to have 24 notes within a 4/4 time, logically I want the notes to be between 16th and 32nd notes, so I need a tuples setup. I can do this broken down into four sets of 6-tuples of 16th notes. This works just fine, and musescore allows me to copy and paste them into new measures as I please. This isn't what I want though: I want one complete passage of 24 notes, and Musescore allows me to do this by using a custom tuple setup: 24/16 upon a 4/4 whole rest gives me a 24 tuple with 24 16-notes.
It works, it looks fine and plays fine, but when I have this complex tuple I no longer can copy it and paste it into another measure: it says tuplet cannot cross barlines, yet it wouldn't cross the barline if it worked properly. I realize as mentioned I can use four sets of 6-tuples and copy/past functionality works, and it makes sense to do this to have pulses within the 24-note phrase, but if that's not what I want for a solution, what can I do? Is this an error that will be fixed in future versions?
Comments
Interestingly enough, this works fine with having 4/3 as a ratio, but 12/8 and 6/4 fail as well (which is consistent as its the same time-division as 24/16).
In reply to Interestingly enough, this by jeetee
Can someone file a bug with steps to reproduce? I might have a fix.
_ratio needs to be "reduced" here https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/blob/423a066c5f19f1512dbaa507ac4…
Not sure if it has other bad effects...
In reply to Can someone file a bug with by [DELETED] 5
#136406: Non-Reduced ratio tuplets of full measure duration not copy-pastable
In reply to Interestingly enough, this by jeetee
P.S. in 4/4 time signature a "Cannot create tuplet of ratio 4/3 for 4/4 duration" error occurs. I'm under the impression that this is normal though.
In reply to P.S. in 4/4 time signature a by worldwideweary
Oh yes, my typo; I was going to write normal triplet there, being 3/2
Similarly, 5/4 works, but 10/8 doesn't.
It seems like only the base forms of the ratios do work.
In reply to Similarly, 5/4 works, but by jeetee
10/2 doesn't copy and paste but 11/2 does for me.
*What?!*
In reply to 10/2 doesn't copy and paste by worldwideweary
As mentioned and in the meantime reported
11/2 can't be simplified
but 10/2 can be to 5/1
In reply to As mentioned and in the by jeetee
Interesting. Thanks.