Handel Gigue in G minor from HWV 432
http://musescore.com/user/41543/scores/78117
This is an arrangement of Handel's Gigue in G minor from HWV 432. Enjoy :)
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| HWV432-5.mscz | 5.91 KB |
Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.
Comments
lumbrius,
thank you for your nice contribution.
You need someone else to proofread (or ~listen). To me it sounds as if there are at least five faulty notes:
bar 7, 3rd beat, last triplet (d instead of eb)
bar 8, 2nd beat, last triplet (a instead of g)
bar 13, 2nd beat, bass line, last triplet (a instead of g)
bar 18, 1st beat, first triplet (f# instead of f)
bar 19, 3rd beat, bass note (g instead of f)
I have not seen the original source of that piece, but these places seem to be wrong - just by listening to them.
Another thing: if you want your score to look professional, you should adjust the bar numbering.
The upbeat does not count as a bar and should be 0.
The first complete bar is bar number 1.
After the repeat sign, make sure, it is the same bar number as the upbeat before the repeat sign.
I hope you don’t mind me pointing this out.
In reply to proof read? by kbundies
The bar numbering is correct.
Well, up to bar 8 at least, as you correctly pointed out:
The bar after the :|| is the remainder of bar 8 and should not get counted, marking as irregular takes care of that
In reply to proof read? by kbundies
them file, attached again.
In reply to the file, attached again. by kbundies
? in attachment names don't seem to work...
In reply to ? in attachment names don't by Jojo-Schmitz
thank you Jojo, now it works!
In reply to ? in attachment names don't by Jojo-Schmitz
Hello Jojo,
did we both fix the score?
Just wondering...
In reply to did we both? by kbundies
I for sure did not, not in any published version at least...
In reply to proof read? by kbundies
Dear kb,
Thank you very much for your remarks. I was using this source from imslp.org: http://imslp.org/wiki/Special:ImagefromIndex/12254
If I'm not wrong, mscz is identical to this source by now. I have replaced it with fixed version from Jojo-Schmitz, who has my thanks for fixing measures :)
Nice!
But are you sure about ....
...the G natural quaver in the bass line of bar 13, an A natural sounds more in tune and....
...the F natural dotted crotchet in the Bass line of bar 19, a G natural sounds more likely...
...and the F natural quaver in bar 18 of the the treble stave sounds as though it ought to be F#
I don't have access to the score so I am relying on my ears, so please accept my apologies if I'm wrong.
Yours
Norman Hart
In reply to Handel Gigue in G minor from HWV 432 by normanhart
Hello Norman,
I rechecked, and my ears did not fool me, everything according to the source on IMSLP.
Also do not be afraid to make use of the „X“ key. It flips the stems according to wish (or to the original) in a very easy way.
I had fun and even added the ornaments, as you can see here: