Bug with "hide empty staves" function + cross-staff barline and system bracket
I've come into a bug in a piano concerto.
1) have a score with piano staves plus orchestra staves (I guess it doesn't have to be a piano...)
2) orchestra staves have a continuous bar-line from top instrument to bottom instrument
3)when the notes are all there, activate "hide empty staves" in the global style.
=> Where the top and/or the bottom instrument doesn't play, ie its staff is hidden, the bug occurs: the bar-line goes messy in varied ways according to whether
- the top instrument is there but not the bottom one (the barline goes up instead of down and no barline for the other instr. down there)
- the top instrument is not there (no barline at all)
I attach a prototype.
hide empty staves bug.mscz
If you then add a system bracket to the orchesta, form top inst. to bottom instr., the hide function will mess it up as well.
Sorry if it has already been reported! Best wishes!
Pascalio
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| hide empty staves bug.mscz | 2.44 KB |
Comments
Can you reproduce the problem with a current nightly build? MuseScore 1.x won't receive further fixes...
I can't reproduce, checked with github-musescore-musesore-2277bc (the latest), self build, on Windows 7
In reply to Can you reproduce the problem by Jojo-Schmitz
hehh sorry but I don't manage to check with a nightly build... I've downloaded and extracted the nightly from http://prereleases.musescore.org/linux/nightly/ put it in /usr/bin/mscore-2 but when I launch it, it says to be mscore-1.3 and the layout problem aren't solved. Sorry I'm no developer... But if said you did have the problem on 1.3, but it was fixed in 2, I'm pretty happy with it!
Sorry if I did not understand, are you sure do not dragged or moved manually the barline?
Take a look to attachments
In reply to @Pascalio by Shoichi
I've opened your score in both, 1.3 and the latest nightly build. In the former I could see missing barlines, in that latter I could not. So I assume whatever the bug was, that it is fixed now (or rather: will be fixed in the next version)
In reply to I've opened your score in by Jojo-Schmitz
Yes me too, in 1.3, the barlines don't cross the staves as they should...
In reply to @Pascalio by Shoichi
Yes I'm sure I didn't do anything to the score except for check "hide empty staves". The messy layout is really produced by musescore-1.*
In reply to no drag or move by Pascalio
...a saved copy of the score *before* you hid the empty staves? Perhaps a backup copy?
Presumably, it should look like my attachment 'Empty Staves Not Hidden.mscz' which was generated from Shoichi's 'hide empty staves C.mscz' (which is posted above).
See if my attachment displays properly for you when you open it and hide the empty staves.
Regards.