Add Placement above/below property for fingering
Reported version
3.0
Priority
P1 - High
Type
Development
Frequency
Once
Severity
S5 - Suggestion
Reproducibility
Always
Status
closed
Regression
No
Workaround
No
Project
Fingering text needs to include letters such as "R", "r", "l", "L" for drummers and be below the notes. Also double combinations such as "rr". I have been using Staff text and a more experienced user in this forum suggested I make this an enhancement request.
Comments
You can already edit the fingering text, so no new feature is needed there. But the ability to set the placement below staff would indeed be nice. I am pretty sure the code now supports this internally, we would just need to expose this in the Inspector and via the "X" command.
https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/pull/4702
It would be good to also add the lettering such as "R" and "L" so that every value would not have to be changed. Otherwise, it would require to change every single one. It would be a nice option when working on percussion. Otherwise, it creates more work than using Staff Text.
I'd suggest making that a separate suggestion.
As mentioned earlier, you can already add any markings you like to a custom palette; you don't really need MuseScore to do that for you. Plus you can use the new fingering mode to quickly enter as many as you like (is, enter one, press Space to move to the next, etc).
But if enough other users express interest in seeing these added to the palette it can certainly be done.
Fingerings need to be able to move onto the staff as well: currently, Fingering and RH Guitar Fingering only allow this for unbeamed notes and String numbers not at all. Placement above/below doesn't address this issue. See #284843: Allow all fingerings to be moved onto the staff.
Fingerings can already be moved onto the staff, simply disable autoplace or user a user text style rather than one of the predefined ones that places the fingering outside the staff. See https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/pull/4730 for a PR that implements a couple of ways to make it easier to disable autoplace in order to do this sort of manual adjustment/
Fixed in branch master, commit 3c093d4a97
fix #284347: support Placement property and flip command for fingering
Fixed in branch master, commit d9f656e246
_Merge pull request #4702 from MarcSabatella/284347-fingering-placement
fix #284347: support Placement property and flip command for fingering_
Fixed in branch 3.0.5, commit ce2eb711ae
_Merge pull request #4702 from MarcSabatella/284347-fingering-placement
fix #284347: support Placement property and flip command for fingering_
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.