Dynamics issue with Mojave
Hello guys,
I have a very annoying issue with the latest version of Musescore: very often it happends that I give a dynamic to a part, but the playback doesn’t play it where I put it but at the beginning of the following bar. I tried to upload a video as example but I can't, so I hope I've been clear. How can I fix it? I’m using a 2017 macbook pro 15” with touchbar, with the latest version of Mojave.
Thank you!
EDIT: I uploaded the issue on youtube. Here is the link: https://youtu.be/52pjiUOqJ80
Comments
Can you attach a score showing the problem?
In reply to Can you attach a score… by jeetee
I tried, but if I make a fragment in a new score it works. I made an unlisted video on youtube, here it is: https://youtu.be/52pjiUOqJ80
In reply to I tried, but if I make a… by solononsivedo
as has been said already: we need a score showing the problem, not a picture or video of it
In reply to as has been said already: we… by Jojo-Schmitz
I manage to do that, here it is
In reply to I manage to do that, here it… by solononsivedo
And which of those doesn't work?
In reply to And which of those doesn't… by Jojo-Schmitz
The problem, in the fragment, is specifically on violin and viola: on my device, the playback plays the "p" at the D of bar n.7, instead of bar n.6. This problem happens also with other dynamics during the whole piece, in all the strings (also the cello)
In reply to I manage to do that, here it… by solononsivedo
I'm not hearing the issue. I'm on version 3.2.3 using CC11 (see https://musescore.org/en/node/290616#Using-CC11) for dynamics. I suspect everyone else is using CC2. I tried it using CC2 and heard the same thing, so this sounds like a CC2 SND bug.
In reply to I tried, but if I make a… by solononsivedo
If you're concerned with copyright, then remove the systems before and after this part.
Also tell us which instrument and hairpin/dynamic to look into specifically
In reply to If you're concerned with… by jeetee
I wasn't concerned with copyright :) It was a very long piece so I wanted to send you one fragment in which there's the problem, but by copy-pasting it in a new file the things worked, so I did as u said, and I don't know if the problem remains on other devices, that's why I made the video.
In reply to I wasn't concerned with… by solononsivedo
The problem, in the fragment, is specifically on violin and viola: on my device, the playback plays the "p" at the D of bar n.7, instead of bar n.6
In reply to The problem, in the fragment… by solononsivedo
Ah, I see (hear). Strange...
Not restricted to Mojave, Windows 7 too
In reply to The problem, in the fragment… by solononsivedo
I can confirm this over here, not sure what causes it though.
I even tried removing the p there and placing a fff instead; no effect. It seems as if somehow all/any dynamic marking in there is ignored. Also replacing the notes in there with a copy from m3 didn't solve this either.
In reply to The problem, in the fragment… by solononsivedo
Trial and error shows me the pedal marking on the piano seems to be the culprit, no idea why. Delete it and the dynamics work as expected.
In reply to Trial and error shows me the… by Marc Sabatella
I did it, and it works. Thank you!