Either I no longer understand anything or we did not understand each other.
I record a song and convert it to midi and I sent you the result with MuseScore.
I wouldn't know what else to do. For years always done this way
so I have now tried everything again
I work with Melodyne; ProTools and I have to say, these are top programs.
i worked with Finale until the year before last and the midi's were always taken over correctly. Now I had to change because it doesn't work with my Mac anymore.
I think Musecore is great, but the only thing to do now is to take the midi correctly.
Even with old midi's that I have written a book it doesn't work.......they are all quantized.......
If on importing that MIDI into MuseScore you tick the box "Human perfomance" ("Menschlicher Aufführung") and hit "Apply" ("Anwenden") the result looks quite a bit better.
I don't see any bug, no bogus behavoir in MuseScore though. It is trying to make the best of that apparently unquantized input.
MIDI is just not a good way to convey music notation
Comments
What is the actual problem? Sample MIDI? Steps to reproduce?
What is the Workaround?
In reply to (No subject) by Jojo-Schmitz
the problem is as follows:
I am importing my midi file and it is accepted but mistaken.
Working with ProTools
Sample file needed. What is the workaround?
This was imported 1:1 and looks like this
oder ich hab falsche Einstellungen im Programm
That's the (allegedly) bogus result. The source, the MIDI file is needed
Looks like that is badly quantisized
In reply to That's the (allegedly) bogus… by Jojo-Schmitz
this is the midi source
No, this is the MuseScore mscz result of importing a MIDI file. that MIDI file is needed
certainly not a blocker, as you apparently got it imported
MIDI import often ends up like this
In reply to certainly not a blocker, as… by Jojo-Schmitz
Either I no longer understand anything or we did not understand each other.
I record a song and convert it to midi and I sent you the result with MuseScore.
I wouldn't know what else to do. For years always done this way
Send the midi that led to that mscz
In general in your DAW quantize it before importing in MuseScore
In reply to Send the midi that led to… by Jojo-Schmitz
so I have now tried everything again
I work with Melodyne; ProTools and I have to say, these are top programs.
i worked with Finale until the year before last and the midi's were always taken over correctly. Now I had to change because it doesn't work with my Mac anymore.
I think Musecore is great, but the only thing to do now is to take the midi correctly.
Even with old midi's that I have written a book it doesn't work.......they are all quantized.......
thanks a lot
Lee Jones
Share. the. midi.!
In reply to Share. the. midi.! by Jojo-Schmitz
i have share the midi
No, you shared "Adagio Pianoforte mid.mscz", not a MIDI (.mid), but a MuseScore (.mscz) file
so that is for me a midi file of a piano I made from my Adagio version. I really don't know how else to create a midi
No we're talking... this is the midi file I asked for
In reply to so that is for me a midi… by leejones07
Printout of midi file
If on importing that MIDI into MuseScore you tick the box "Human perfomance" ("Menschlicher Aufführung") and hit "Apply" ("Anwenden") the result looks quite a bit better.
I don't see any bug, no bogus behavoir in MuseScore though. It is trying to make the best of that apparently unquantized input.
MIDI is just not a good way to convey music notation