Three bugs.
1.The octave mark in the low range does not move higher with the note.
2. The score is typed according to the bass position, but after saving in xml format, it is changed to the second part of the treble staff
3.After saving in xml format, the ending lines of the staff are separated and not connected together.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| book2.png | 498.55 KB |
| score2.png | 125.06 KB |
| 4.xml | 60.36 KB |
Comments
When posting a potential bug report,. what we really need is a sample score we can load and then precise step by step instructions we can follow in order to reproduce the bug. As it is, I'm not really understanding any of the three things you are describing from just pictures and one line descriptions.
In reply to When posting a potential bug… by Marc Sabatella
I couldn't work out what was meant from the descriptions but the images show the issues pretty well. Having the 8va mark move with the notes into the upper staff is an interesting one, to be honest I wouldn't expect to see it doubled up like that (as per the book2 png which I assume is a photo of a traditionally engraved score), it logically applies to the whole staff anyway. I'd just hide it in the lower staff if there are no notes for it to apply to.
Not sure about the barline issue, is the XML format supposed to capture all that information (about barline breaks between staves etc.)?
In reply to I couldn't work out what was… by Dylan Nicholson1
(I can reproduce that barline disconnecting issue easily too - just create a score with piano staves that have connected barlines, export as musicxml with the default options, then re-open, and there's a break in final barline. Only the final one, oddly. I'd say that's a genuine bug)
In reply to (I can reproduce that… by Dylan Nicholson1
I can also see it's been reported before: https://musescore.org/en/node/290694
Note that it's just a problem with the import - the musicxml file itself is fine and should display correctly in other software that can import that format.
In reply to I can also see it's been… by Dylan Nicholson1
Rather (or better) #290694: [MusicXML Import] Final barlines no longer spanning staves on imported MusicXML files (notated as [#290694])