Tuning change after instrument change
Reported version
3.6
Type
Functional
Frequency
Once
Severity
S3 - Major
Reproducibility
Always
Status
duplicate
Regression
No
Workaround
Yes
Project
In a piano score: change the bass clef to some percussion instrument (e.g. Finger clap) for any number of measures and then change back to piano. The notes in the piano score after reverting to piano will be off by a third; i.e. the notes are just as the treble clef; FACE instead of ACEG.
Comments
Sample score please
Confirmed
Workaround: explicitly change to bass clef
In reply to Confirmed Workaround:… by Jojo-Schmitz
How did you add the instrument change? The pallet text is broken for transposing instruments, but adding the instrument change Text from the [Add] menu works ok. See #320828: Change Instrument Palette Text does not recognise current instrument leading to incorrect transpositions
I haven't tested changing to drums - are they treated as transposing perhaps?
I just added an instrument change text from the text palette. I'm not aware that this is different from the menu entry?
While drums are certainly not transposing instruments, they are treated different enough from 'normal' instruments, so yes, that other issue might well be related
But indeed the palette text is bogus, it works fine with the menu entry, even with a drum staff
So this is a duplicate
And using the menu is the better workaround
In reply to But indeed the palette text… by Jojo-Schmitz
Not particularly related to the reported problem, but I also see the OP says "In a piano score: change the bass clef to some percussion instrument (e.g. Finger clap) for any number of measures and then change back to piano. " Adding an instrument change to either of the two piano staves changes the whole instrument, not just the half to which the change is applied. It is not possible to have upper stave = piano, lower stave = finger clap (snap?), unless the individual piano staves have been created separately as two different instruments each with piano sound.
Both the palette and the menu apply it to the selected staff. But indeed affect both.