Pickup measure & repeats

• Nov 26, 2024 - 19:18

Hi there fellow engravers,
I have a doubt regarding an engraving technical issue.

Which of the two endings is the correct one? I want a repeat from the top. Is ending 1 ok? Or should the last measure be written fully and just run it as a normal repeat without the pickup measure?

The pickup measure is 1 quarter note. Sometimes I've seen the last measure is reduced in value to match the pickup. What is the purpose of that? I hope my explanation makes sense!


Comments

If you don't leave out the fourth beat, then that repeat measure will have five beats and the repeated four structure has a hiccup. (This sort of thing is occasionally desirable, but probably not here.) Try, for example, including that fourth beat in the volta measure and play it: count the beats.

For myself, I would write the full measure under Volta 1 and have a start repeat at the beginning of the first full measure, rather than repeating to the pickup measure. Like this:

20241128 141320 - repeat to pickup.jpg

Either way works correctly.

Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.