Reprise with a different beginning
Hello,
I'd like to make a score with a reprise, and a different beginning the second time, I don't really know how to do that, here is my try in a joined file !
I also tried with the 2 and 1 indications inverted, won't work as well.
Thanks for your help !
EDIT: as this may look confusing:
-the 2nd time bar should not be played the first time
-the first time bar should not be played the second time.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Reprise.mscz | 4.11 KB |
Comments
Like this?
1st measure, start repeat, 2nd and 3rd measure, alternate 1st meaure with volta 1, end repeat
In reply to Like this? 1st measure, start by Jojo-Schmitz
But here, the first beginning is played again the second time, the 2nd beginning doesn't come instead of the first one :)
In reply to But here, the first beginning by Ladee
No the 1st masure is outside and before the repeated section and the 2nd is moved to the end of the repeated section but with a '1st time only' volta
So it plays 1,2,3,4(or alternate1),2,3,5...
In reply to No the 1st masure is outside by Jojo-Schmitz
The file you sent plays 1,2,3 - 1bis 1,2,3
It's really close to what I expect, but I'd like:
1,2,3 - 1bis, 2, 3
In reply to The file you sent plays 1,2,3 by Ladee
That's exactly what my file Plays
Edit: oh no, I forgot the start repeat barline in measure 2
Try this
In reply to That's exactly what my file by Jojo-Schmitz
Here, it plays 1,2,3, then 1bis,1,2,3,4 (the silence)
Btw, I'm using musescore 2, if that can make a difference...?
In reply to That's exactly what my file by Jojo-Schmitz
Okay... I thought you had updated the file, but I see now !
In reply to Okay... I thought you had by Ladee
Dman, it didn't sabe that barline!
Next attempt...
In reply to Dman, it didn't sabe that by Jojo-Schmitz
That's perfect :)
In reply to But here, the first beginning by Ladee
May be easier like this:
In reply to May be easier like this: by MichLeon
EXACTLY
Thanks a lot for your answer !
I'll add more text in the score next time, as you did...
In reply to Like this? 1st measure, start by Jojo-Schmitz
Here's probably what Jojo meant?
In reply to Here's probably what Jojo by Jm6stringer
Thanks too !
In reply to Here's probably what Jojo by Jm6stringer
of course. but for some stupid reason the begin repeat hasn't been saved in my example ...
In reply to of course. but for some by Jojo-Schmitz
Uh oh... looks that something went wrong for me... what did I do wrong ?
It starts not from the reprise, but at the beginning, again !
I joined the file.
In reply to Uh oh... looks that something by Ladee
I don't see a start repeat bar anywhere, so repeating from the beginning is correct. If you want it to repeat back to somewhere else, you need to add a start repeat bar to that measure from the Barlines palette.
In reply to I don't see a start repeat by Marc Sabatella
...do we have both this on screen ? (cf: file)
If yes, then I missed something.
In reply to ...do we have both this on by Ladee
The file you uploaded does not have the start repeat in measure 2. The picture shows that repeat, so it should play correctly, but the version of the file you uploaded is missing that start repeat and that is why it does not.
In reply to The file you uploaded does by Marc Sabatella
This is very very weird because it is the same file version. I don't get it, I will talk about it to the developers. Thanks for answering !
In reply to The file you uploaded does by Marc Sabatella
If you mean the developers of the software, I am one of them :-). At this point there have been several different versions of the file posted, I suspect you simply uploaded the wrong one. If I add a start repeat and save it, it works just fine. I have uploaded the fixed version.
In reply to If you mean the developers of by Marc Sabatella
Niced !
Indeed your version works. But in my own, the problem remains. As I don't want to look like taking you for a fool, here I go:
a_saving the file (instruments added since then)
b_taking a screen
c_sending you both
So we are sure I sent you what I see, and that in my own, it won't work.
In reply to Niced ! Indeed your version by Ladee
Hmm, I am not sure how you are adding the repeat barline, but it does not seem to be correct. I can see information in the file that suggests you did try to add a start repeat somehow, but it is not the way it is supposed to look. You should be adding the start repeat barline from the Barlines palette - either drag it to measure 2, or select measure 2 then double click it in the palette (or select the barline itself and double click). It looks like maybe you tried using the Inspector to change a regular barline into a start repeat barline. That isn't really supposed to work, and is normally disabled in most situations. Somehow it seems you got around that. Can you describe more specifically how you added this? It's probably a bug that whatever you did appeared to work.
Anyhow, if you add correctly from the palette, all should be well.
In reply to Hmm, I am not sure how you by Marc Sabatella
I dragged it from the barlines palette :) I don't know what the Inspector is. I tried it in an empty file, it worked perfectly. Maybe it had something to do with the volta, as I deleted an existing one near the ghost barline.
It looks like the same problem Jojo-Schmidtz had when he wanted to upload the files btw. On my side, if it happens again, I'll properly report it, step by step !
EDIT: When I closed the program and started it again, the barline had disappeared, and I could properly add it.
In reply to I dragged it from the by Ladee
Same problem I had yesterday, twice. I'm pretty sure I saved it, then uploaded, yet the start repeat was missing
In reply to Same problem I had yesterday, by Jojo-Schmitz
I can tell you that the barline is there in the bad version, but stored improperly - it's an attrribute of the individual abrlines rather than of the measure as it should be So it looks like someone tried to force each each specific barlibe, staff by staff, to *look* like a start repeat, while not actually setting the measure to be a start repeat. I've never heard of this happening before, so I guess it must be something odd about how you both went about it, or maybe something odd about the original file.