multi-notes tremolo not played back correctly

• Apr 22, 2015 - 08:45
Type
Functional
Severity
S4 - Minor
Status
closed
Project
MuseScore

Tremolos consisting of three or more notes don't always play correctly:
tremolo.png

The tremolo marked with 1 playes the G only once and repeats the outer notes (C and Eb).
The tremolo marked with 2 playes only C and Eb.
The tremolo marked with 3 however playes correctly.

Problem appears in release v2.0 and 8b62cda on Kubuntu 14.04

Attachment Size
tremolo.png 3.54 KB
Tremolo.mscz 4.55 KB

Comments

• Apr 23, 2015 - 22:13

I think it should sound like this:
NOT FOUND: 01

I already have looked at the code, and your link is exactly pointing to the problem (line768): the two chords don't have the same number of notes.
The PlayEvent list of a note would have to contain entries for more than one (sounding) midi note. In the second example, although there's only one note in the first chord, there need to be played two notes every other 16th. But NoteEvent doesn't seem to support this.

Attachment Size
tremolo2.png 2.68 KB

Reply