Musescore 3.6 crashes when opening a score with corrupted part
Reported version
3.6
Type
Functional
Frequency
Few
Severity
S2 - Critical
Reproducibility
Always
Status
closed
Regression
Yes
Workaround
Yes
Project
After I updated to 3.6, this file crashes upon opening it.
Attachment | Size |
---|---|
Pedestrians_and_Pussycats.mscz | 195.89 KB |
Fix version
3.6.1
Comments
Every time I try to open this file, MuseScore crashes. I'm fairly certain one of the parts is corrupted or something.
In reply to Every time I try to open… by integrationbyhearts
The last part (Drums) of your score was corrupt (empty measures)
After removing and recreating this part, the file opens fine now in version 3.6.
See: 1 Pedestrians_and_Pussycats_0.mscz
However, the same score opens in 3.5.2 with the same corruption. Don't know really why right now (ie opens in 3.5.2 and not in 3.6)
Further checking needed.
Well, crashing on a corrupt score is basically by design... with a corruption anything can happen.
Anyway, if it crashes in 3.6 but not in 3.5 that's a regression.
And if re-generating the part fixes it, there's a workaround.
What'd be really important would be to find out how it got corrpt in the first place
For me it opens fine in a current build under the debugger, but that doesn't prove anything was fixed since 3.6, could be just one of those bugs involving non-deterministic behavior, like depending on an uninitialized variable, that differs between systems or in debug versus non-debug builds.
Ooops, except while typing the above,. it crashed on its own during the autosave I guess. Not a true crash, but an assertion failure, so still not hugely useful for debugging purposes. It just tells me what we already know - there is an empty measure in the drum part.
Yes I'm having this same problem with some certain scores
The programs crashes when opening a corrupt score. I reinstalled MuseScore 3.6 but to no avail. Not sure how the file became corrupted. I am working on another project without any problems.
I encounter the same problem and even after correcting the corrupted measurement with the V 3.5, when I try to open the repaired score with V3.6 musecore crashes...
We'd need the corrupt score
Thank you very much for your help on this.
My files also crash. I've created them in Version 3.5.x, opened them in 3.6 yesterday, edited some parts... Today I tried to reopen them, but they crash.
Tribal_Engel_v.0.1 --> opens fine, was created in 3.5.x, not edited in 3.6
Tribal_Engel_v.0.2 --> started as a copy from above, was later opened and edited in 3.6., now crashes.
I am not sure what kind of corruption could have happened. I keep the files in Dropbox, so maybe saving them while Dropbox was synchronizing could be an issue? But I highly doubt that, Dropbox manages that quite well....
EDIT: Sorry, i didn't mean to change the status of "Workaround" and "Regression"! I cannot edit it back :(
EDIT 2: removed files again.
The recently posted scores are not corrupt, they are simply examples of the known issue where the start repeat barline caused a crash in continuous view, which is fixed for 3.6.1. Here are versions saved with continuous view turned off to avoid the crash.
In reply to The recently posted scores… by Marc Sabatella
Thank you so much! I can open it again!
And sorry, I didn't know that this was a known issue, I searched before in the issue tracker but I only found this ticket applicable.
On a side note: Could you edit your comment to remove the "tribal_engel" file? I was told that it is not a good idea to post my yet-unpublished-work on publicly available places... I am still learning :D
Done. But, not sure who told you that - there is no harm whatsoever in posting music to a support forum or issue tracker, and actually the timestamp serves as definitive proof that you possessed the music at certain date. In the extremely unlikely event that a copyright violation ever occurred, pointing to a timestamped Internet post would be an effective bit of evidence.
The same happened with my file, which worked fine before the update. All my other files still work fine, but this one crashes Musescore every time. I saw other people in this thread fixed their corrupted scores, but how exactly can I do it?
Try this. You could installed the 3.5.2 Portable App, open that score and switch to Page View. Or just wait for 3.6.1, This score caused a different problem than is at hand in this issue. See #315529: MuseScore 3.6 crashes on open of a file with start repeat in continuous view
Good news, the first attached score (https://musescore.org/en/node/316079#comment-1055235) opens just fine now in version 3.6.1 :d0fc8e9
(so, although the Drums part remains corrupt)
I guess something else in the other improvments between 3.6 and 3.6.1 allowed to fix this.
EDIT: and for the last one (Super Mario Maker), in first glance, I note nothing particular
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.