MIDI File

• Nov 2, 2022 - 20:44

Can I save my file as a MIDI file?


Comments

The difference being, "save" implies you're really saving the whole score in a way that would allow you to then load it again and have it back as it was. Whereas really, MIDI means throwing away most of the information, so loading it will not give you back what you started with at all. Not that this means you can't export as MIDI in order to load into some other program, while realizing it won't have all the info that was in MuseScore. Just be sure to save normally too.

In reply to by SingingJenny

Again, there is no such thing as saving as MIDi, just exporting. If you want to save you file - and presumably you do, otherwise your work is gone - you need to save normally.

When I mean is, exporting to MIDI gives you a file, yes, But if you then load that file into MuseScore, you'll find most of the work you did is gone. you'd see dots on the staff, eys, but the notes and rhythms might be spelled differently, all text will be gone, all articulations gone, all formatting gone, etc. Because MIDI isn't designed for that.

So, exporting to MIDi is fine if you have a program that needs a MIDI file - exporting to MIDI isn't a problem in itself. But, always be sure to actually save your work also if you ever want to see it again. Exporting is not a substitute for saving, it's something you can optionally do in addition to saving.

In reply to by SingingJenny

MIDI is not a score format, it is mechanical playback instructions for electronic instruments. As such it does not differentiate between a Gb and an F#. It does not contain notational durations, but "hit this note that hard for x milliseconds", therefor it has no concept of staccato notation or tuplets either.
Since its only playback instructions, it does not contain texts added to your score, it does not contain dynamic markings or hairpins, only the result of them. It does not contain page information or staff size information. It does not contain notation elements nor their position.

Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.