Bug on export in MP3 (v 4.4.4)
When you want to export one of the voice (SATB) in mp3, the mp3 file obtained is "blank" (nothing inside). It was working on previous version.
Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.
Comments
Please post a score, so we can help.
Working for me. I created a score using the "SATB + Piano" template. Input notes in each voice. Exported both individually and all at once. In all cases, all the parts exported properly.
Yes, provide your score. In case you don't know How To attach a file, click the link.
[the next day] Yes, I'm running MuS 4.4.4.
In reply to Working for me. I created a… by TheHutch
Thanks for your answer.
Did you take the version 4.4.4 ?
On my side, I can export in mp3 each voice but when i want to read the file it's blank.
Follow attached the file used (but it's the same with all my files)
BR
Olivier
In reply to Thanks for your answer. Did… by Bughin
Then you must have a look on your computer.
My version is OS: Windows 10 (10.0), Arch.: x86_64, MuseScore version (64-bit): 3.6.2.548021803, revision: 3224f34 and it works perfectly.
In reply to Then you must have a look on… by HildeK
So how is that related to the OP's issue not being able to do that with 4.4.4?
OTOH that score stems from 3.6.2...
In reply to Thanks for your answer. Did… by Bughin
I can confirm the issue with 4.4.4. (blank -> siilent, some 2.3MB of silence per voice)
In reply to Thanks for your answer. Did… by Bughin
Same with the latest 4.5
Please report this on GitHub, https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/issues/new/choose
In reply to Same with the latest 4.5… by Jojo-Schmitz
Thanks very much for your tests and confirmation and also for your advice to report on GitHub. I have just done it.
In reply to Thanks for your answer. Did… by Bughin
Thanks for https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/issues/27025
In reply to Thanks for https://github… by Jojo-Schmitz
As workaround: export the file in MusicXLM.
The mp3 export works after that.
In reply to As workaround: export the… by cadiz1
Ok, thanks.
I will try it :-)
In reply to Thanks for your answer. Did… by Bughin
Just trying different things. I don't think any of this will help, but maybe it will *shrug*
OP's score does the same thing (exports blank single voices, but the full mix plays normally) in all the sound formats: .MP3, .WAV, .OGG, .FLAC. MIDI exports normally: full mix plays and so do all single voices.
I tried making minor changes (Pan and Volume) in the Mixer: no effect.
OTOH I can create an SATB score in MU3 and open it in MU4 and export one voice just fine. I wonder what the difference is?