Crescendo line results in decrescendo wedge in musicxml export
Reported version
3.0
Type
Functional
Frequency
Once
Severity
S4 - Minor
Reproducibility
Always
Status
duplicate
Regression
No
Workaround
No
Project
Steps to reproduce:
Enter a few notes and give them a crescendo line (cresc.______)
Export the score to a .musicxml-file
Open the .musicxml-file with an ascii-editor.
You will find:
Expected: wedge type="crescendo".
(Remark: a words / dashes combination would be even better to have a distinction between crescendo wedge and crescendo line, but this is only a suggestion )
Comments
See #272223: [MusicXML export] Text crescendo exported as diminuendo hairpins
Editor cleared my description of the content of the musicxml-file. Used ascii less-than and greater-than signs.
however, you'll find the words 'wedge type="decrescendo" in the musicxml-file.
still a duplicate though
In reply to See #272223: [MusicXML… by Jojo-Schmitz
The change to a line instead of a wedge would be a good thing and this is clearly addressed in the linked report. But exporting diminuendo instead of crescendo is just the wrong way round and I think of it as an mistake which could be corrected easily.
still a duplicate... or at least should be dealt with in the same fix
In reply to Editor cleared my… by manfrhahn
Sorry: Wedge type="diminuendo"
and if not from #272223: [MusicXML export] Text crescendo exported as diminuendo hairpins, then from #284376: Crescendo line is exported as Diminuendo hairpin in musicxml (MXL)