Repeat with multiple endings issue
I've been spending a few days to do the testing. The whole volta repeat is fine except the 3rd time starts from 2nd bar instead of the 1st bar. Anybody can help ?
Thanks a lot.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| 2 Volta test.mscz | 2 KB |
Comments
Generally speaking, MuseScore is a notation program rather than a general purpose playback program, and it does not even try to follow complex repeat setups. I'm not sure if it's at all possible to get it to do anything like what you have in mind. Best bet is simply turn off the playback of repeats.
In reply to Generally speaking, MuseScore by Marc Sabatella
Thx, Marc.
It's a pity. Cannot make audio file w correct endings for friends' ref.
Have a good day.
In reply to Thx, Marc. It's a pity. by Tonykeung
If your goal is making an audio representation of your score, why don't you export the score as a MIDI file, then import the resulting MIDI file using a sequencer, then edit your repeats and whatever else you need using the editing features of the sequencer, then save the results as audio file (or as MIDI again)?.
If you don't have any sequencer, there are many free solution available. As an example, you could consider Podium Free or Logic Fun or Temper.
In reply to Cheat suggestion by Aldo
Thank you so much for yr very considerated advice, Aldo.
I hope I can try when i'm free.
If anyone can fix it w musescore, that would be great.
Cheers,
In reply to Cheat suggestion by Aldo
Thank you so much for yr very considerated advice, Aldo.
I hope I can try when i'm free.
If anyone can fix it w musescore, that would be great.
Cheers,
In reply to To sequencer expert by Tonykeung
An easy workaround.
Produce a version of the piece in MuseScore with written out repeats using copy and paste.
Tada! Job done :)
In reply to An easy workaround. Produce a by ChurchOrganist
Hi, ChurchOrganist,
Thanks for your advice.
Copy & paste is not the issue. The issue is "The 3rd time repeat starts from bar 2 instead of bar 1".
If you have time, pls take a look my attachment of the orginal question.
Thx & Rgds,
In reply to The 3rd time repeat starts from bar 2 instead of bar 1 by Tonykeung
That is understood, but another problem is "Cannot make audio file w correct endings for friends' ref.", and that can be solved as per ChurchOrganist's advice
In reply to That is understood, but by Jojo-Schmitz
HI, Jojo-Schmitz,
Is it possible you can edit my attached file to show me how to have audio files w correct endings(the 3rd repeat starts from the 1st bar) ?
Thanks.
In reply to HI, Jojo-Schmitz, Is it by Tonykeung
here we go...
In reply to here we go... by Jojo-Schmitz
I got it, thanks to chruchorganist & HI, Jojo-Schmitz.
Have a great weekend !
Tony
In reply to The 3rd time repeat starts from bar 2 instead of bar 1 by Tonykeung
...but when I play your original posted score I hear a perfect 4th (C & F notes) being played at volta '2'. It sounds as if MuseScore is not actually starting from bar 2 at the repeat; but, in fact, it plays bar #4 & bar #1 simultaneously. Then it proceeds to bar #2.
Also, as the logical position of the volta 2,4 encompasses only a single measure, writing it out as ChurchOrganist suggested (and as Jojo did in his attachment) will allow for proper playback.
However, if you wish to extend the volta's logical position to more than one measure, see:
http://musescore.org/en/handbook/volta
Regards.
In reply to @Tonykeung...Not to confuse the issue... by Jm6stringer
yes, you're right, bar 4 & bar 1 plays simultaneously at the end of the 2nd repeat.
I can fix with it with churchorganist's advice.
But with yr advice to extend 1 bar of Volta 2,4, still doesn't work with attachment.
You have any idea ?
By the way, can U tell me how to make 3 different endings(problem attached) ?
Have a good weekend !
There are know issues: #4525: Repeats with more than 3 endings, #6091: Multiple volta bracket endings playback incorrectly, #8604: Better control of repeats and jumps for playback not yet fixed.