Removing check from line visible has no effect
Reported version
3.0
Priority
P1 - High
Type
Functional
Frequency
Once
Severity
S3 - Major
Reproducibility
Always
Status
closed
Regression
Yes
Workaround
No
Project
As in the title. Insert a Cresc.----- and remove the check from visible and the line does not turn invisible.
Marked as critical because there is no easy workaround short of making the entire dynamic change invisible and using text.
Don't forget to make sure the palette display is also correct.
Comments
I believe this is the 3.0 version of #271236: "Line visible" property not honored on screen for text lines. It seems the line actually is invisible but doesn't gray out. It disappears if you turn off View / Show Invisible (might have to wait for next relayout though, or toggle the setting in Inspector again). Near as I can tell, the PR for that issue was applied to 2.3 but never to master.
In reply to I believe this is the 3.0… by Marc Sabatella
the PR for that issue was applied to 2.3 but never to master
This was my suspicion.
The fix for the master branch is much simpler. See https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/pull/4276.
When you copy the line (cresc.--- e.g.) to the palette, the state of the Line Visible check box returns to visible. Let me know if I need a different bug report for this.
When you copy the line (cresc.--- e.g.) to the palette, the state of the Line Visible check box returns to visible.
I am not sure I understand what you mean, but it seems unrelated. A different bug report seems appropriate, along with detailed instructions and perhaps a gif.
Fixed in branch master, commit b06bc97905
fix #279176: Removing check from line visible has no effect
Fixed in branch master, commit a62850b9e9
Merge pull request #4276 from mattmcclinch/279176-line-visible
fix #279176: Removing check from line visible has no effect
It has a visible effect with that fix now, but doesn't survive a save/close/open nor an export to PDF
See https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/pull/4294 for a patch that fixes the save/close/open issue and the printing issue. (Export to PDF is considered a form of printing).
Fixed in branch master, commit 08421e2085
fix #279176: "Line visible" property not honored when printing or after save/close/open
Fixed in branch master, commit 428542a52a
Merge pull request #4294 from mattmcclinch/279176-line-visible
fix #279176: "Line visible" property not honored when printing or after save/close/open
Works localy now, but not on "Save online" I guess that is to be expected, as the backend needs to get updated too?
Also, the line remains on screen (greyed out) if you uncheck View / Show Invisible.
Also, the line remains on screen (greyed out) if you uncheck View / Show Invisible.
I updated my patch for #279510: Invisible pedal marks visible on musescore.com to include a fix for this as well.
Of course, #276384: Show invisible does not work until screen is redrawn is still an issue....
Fixed in branch master, commit 44b0d40f00
fix #279510: Pedal marks are still visible when set to invisible
fix #279176: Hide invisible text lines when "Show invisible" is unchecked
Automatically closed -- issue fixed for 2 weeks with no activity.