Reset (Ctrl+R) does not reset leading space
Searched the issue tracker, but didn't find the issue.
Displace a note by doubleclick and L/R arrow. Try to reset the position with Ctrl+R. Expected result: leading space will be reset to zero. Actual result: nothing happens.
Are my expectations not correct or is this a bug?
Win10 (64-bit): 3.1.0.7078, e26f7c4
Comments
reset the position with Ctrl+R after selecting the note or measure?
MuseScore version (32-bit): 3.1.0., d4b829c seems to work regularly
In reply to reset the position with Ctrl… by Shoichi
Not in my case. Selecting note or measure resets the X-offset of the chord but not the leading space.
In reply to Not in my case. Selecting… by [DELETED] 135427
Attach the *.mscz file or an example. Someone else will be able to take a look at it
In reply to Attach the *.mscz file or an… by Shoichi
Thanks!
Reset leading space fails.mscz
In reply to Thanks! [inline:Reset… by [DELETED] 135427
Effectively, it only seems to work via Inspector.
In reply to Effectively, it only seems… by Shoichi
Exactly. Shall I report it as an issue?
In reply to Exactly. Shall I report it… by [DELETED] 135427
I don't know if it already exists, but you can proceed, in doubt.
In reply to I don't know if it already… by Shoichi
Actually I'm now in doubt if my expectations are correct. A global reset of a measure - all Chordoffsets plus leading space(s) could be too agressive. May be someone else minds to react what one reasonably might expect? If it's considered too agressive my question could turn in a feature request.
In reply to Actually I'm now in doubt if… by [DELETED] 135427
I personally like Ctrl+R to reset everything and am annoyed when there is something it doesn't. I would say I understand why leading space might be special, in which case, a separate "reset leading space" command could be a good idea (much as we also have a separate "reset layout stretch").
In reply to I personally like Ctrl+R to… by Marc Sabatella
In that case: no reset glyph for leading space in the Inspector, so no expectations in that respect. And no risk of suddenly destroying a finetuned layout.
The amount of leading space has to be visible somewhere and would stay in the Inspector.
(Just as the amount of stretch is visible in 'Measure Properties'.)
And a separate command 'Reset leading space' in the Tools menu, with an assignable shortcut.
Are there other aspects I don't realize at the moment?
If not, shall I make an issue as a feature request instead of reporting it as a bug?
In reply to In that case: no reset glyph… by [DELETED] 135427
I'm in agreement. ctrl+r should reset everything to the default style. Auto place should always turn on, the colors should return to default, and all user offsets should be set to zero. Only the notes and duration of the chord should remain the same.
In reply to I'm in agreement. ctrl+r… by mike320
An interaction with the selection filter (with possible implementations).
In reply to I'm in agreement. ctrl+r… by mike320
So if I understand you correctly: Ctrl+R must be a total reset of any change by the user.
So you disagree with the idea of giving 'Reset leading space' its own command?
In reply to So if I understand you… by [DELETED] 135427
That is my view. I was actually agreeing with your initial concern that leading space was not affected by ctrl+r.
In reply to In that case: no reset glyph… by [DELETED] 135427
I don't have strong feelings on this myself and am interested in seeing the consensus.
In reply to I don't have strong feelings… by Marc Sabatella
Issue created: Reset (Ctrl+R) does not reset leading space.
https://musescore.org/en/node/290165
In reply to Issue created: Reset (Ctrl+R… by [DELETED] 135427
#290165: Ctrl+R does not reset leading space to link this thread to the issue.