.mxl bongos play as note
I always listen to my .mxl before I upload it to the postprocessor. This time, and I don't remember encountering this issue before, the bongos play as notes on the .mxl, but sound fine as bongos on the MP3. I don't want to send it up the line if they are supposed to sound as bongos on the .mxl.
Could one of you fine wizards determine if my .mxl is playing correctly? And if it's not, do you have a solution?
Thanks very much in advance! <3
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| music174_175_1.mscz | 39.8 KB |
Comments
The mscz sounds fine, no idea what your mxl sounds like...
In reply to The mscz sounds fine, no… by Jojo-Schmitz
Indeed, the .mxl file sounds different.
The bongo sounded like a violin. (Looks like a compression error)
Applied an instrument change and replaced the violin with the bongo.
If I export your file in an uncompressed format (.musicxml), this error does not occur.
In reply to Indeed, the .mxl file sounds… by Ben Lindeboom
Which .mxl???
In reply to Indeed, the .mxl file sounds… by Ben Lindeboom
OK, if I open that mscz, export it as mxl and import that indeed the bongos sound like violins
Same happens with .musicxml (unsurprisingly, it'd be a rather bad bug if that would beghave differently)
In 4.2 that is, 3.6.2 does import both with bongo sound! So there's a bug in MusicXML import on 4.2 (maybe earlier in 4.x too), please report that on GitHub, https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/issues/new/choose
In reply to OK, if I open that mscz,… by Jojo-Schmitz
You are right about the export of .musicxml in Ms 4.2.0.
I tried to import the file in Ms 4.1.1, which led to a programme crash.
In reply to Indeed, the .mxl file sounds… by Ben Lindeboom
It is getting worse: 4.1.1 even crashes on the musicxml and the mxl
In reply to Indeed, the .mxl file sounds… by Ben Lindeboom
I've now reported it in https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/issues/20654
In reply to I've now reported it in… by Jojo-Schmitz
Thanks, everyone. It's going into an HTML that will be uploaded to Project Gutenberg. The MP3 file sounds fine. Most people will listen to that. A few may want to upload the ,mxl to their own transcription software. By then, it will work or not work for them. They can replace it with their own program notes. Or not. I'll leave a Transcriber's Note to go with the file.
Ya'll da BEST! <3