Missing cleft change in part notation
I have a few times found a problem with part notation cleft change. This happens only in PART notation during multiple rest period. It may not be usual to do cleft change before there are notes but sometimes this prolongs the bar and moves all parts ahead in the score.
I attach one situlation where Violoncello has cleft chage on bar 22, third of the merged rests. I moved it to next bar and it got visible.
I think I can hunt these rare occasions easily but very annoing. I have seen this work (breaking the multiple rest) so it does not always happen. Also, it will recover if removed placed in the same place again. But at some point it can dissapear again.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| missing cleft.jpg | 47.44 KB |
Comments
I haven't been able to reproduce this. Are you putting the clef change in the score? Or the part?
In reply to I haven't been able to… by bobjp
The change is in the score. It seems to be OK when the cleft splits the multiple rest into two multiple rests. But if it is 2 last bar and the rest of it would need to be single bars. Also, it seems to be OK first but when the part is edited for label positions and some readjustment happens on page/line level the problem reappears. Very complex error and I have 2 on 1000 bar score.
Other labels seem not to have same problem and they split the multiple rests correctly. The score is always OK and plays correctly. I guess the part plays OK as well but the player would get into problems...
Below similar score that produces the same part error.
Please share the score
In reply to Please share the score by Jojo-Schmitz
It is on Musescore but parts are not included. Here is an earlier version still with the problem, just this movement bar 22.
In reply to It is on Musescore but parts… by jounip
The clef change is placed in an otherwise empty measure. Hide empty measures is turned on by default in the parts. Move the clef change to immediately before the next note (measure 23).
In reply to It is on Musescore but parts… by jounip
Or disable multimeasure rests, right-click the measure with the clef change, measure properties, tix 'break multimeasture rests, enable multimeasure rests again.
To me this seems to be a bug, multimeasure rests should get automagacially get interrupted at clef changes.
See #285423: Mid-measure clef changes do break multimeasure rests, but don't show the changed clef
In reply to Or disable multimeasure… by Jojo-Schmitz
Yes, I have moved the changes to not empty bars - those that I have found!
In reply to Yes, I have moved the… by jounip
See the workarounds mentioned in the above mentioned issue
The timeline (F12) might help in finding them