Grace Notes No Longer Play?
Ever since the new update, no type of grace note produces any sort of sound. Is this intentional? If not, how do I fix it?
Ever since the new update, no type of grace note produces any sort of sound. Is this intentional? If not, how do I fix it?
Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.
Comments
Which version did you update to?
Only grace notes after don't play back and never did, all others to and ever did.
On my version ( OS: Windows , Arch.: x86_64, MuseScore version (32-bit): 2.3.1, revision: 0899e9d) only Acciaccatura produces a sound. Other grace notes have no sound.
In reply to On my version ( OS: Windows … by Adalbi Atskanov
Hmm, indeed, Appoggiaturas don't sound anymore, apparently since 2.2(.1), they do play in 2.1.
Now reported in #274831: Regression: Appoggiaturas don't play back anymore
And closed again, as I can't reproduce (not sure why I thought I could earlier), check the attached, produced with the just released 2.3.2
In reply to On my version ( OS: Windows … by Adalbi Atskanov
I'm confused. After an app restart they do sound, but the duration is quite different from the real example http://www.music.mcgill.ca/acf/example2-2.php.
In reply to I'm confused. After an app… by Adalbi Atskanov
I think the notation in that example it wrong, those Appoggiaturas (long grace notes) sound like Acciaccaturas (short grace notes)
From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appoggiatura
The time subtracted is generally half the time value of the principal note, though in simple triple or compound meters, for example, it might receive two thirds of the time.
I updated to version 2.3.1, and for me neither accacciature nor appoggiature make any sound.
In reply to I updated to version 2.3.1,… by Owlman142
Can you try again? Seems a couple of other people thought they saw this then it went away. If it persists, please attach the score with the problem.
In reply to Can you try again? Seems a… by Marc Sabatella
The score is here: https://musescore.com/owlman142/atb For some reason the grace notes play in the piccolo and flute parts, but not in the snare drum part in the beginning.
In reply to The score is here: https:/… by Owlman142
Hmm, I can hear that too. I wonder if this is something about the MDL extension - do you have that installed?
And I can actually get the same effect with other instruments if I make the grace note the same pitch as the main note. Or maybe it has to do with the code for detecting overlapping pitches on the same channel, which I know has changed recently?
In reply to Hmm, I can hear that too. I… by Marc Sabatella
I do have MDL installed, so I don't think its that.
In reply to I do have MDL installed, so… by Owlman142
That's part of my point - I have MDL installed, too, and was wondering if the changes made for it somehow are getting in the way. But - try changing the pitch of the grace note then playing back. I can hear the notes sounding more or less simultaneously. I suspect that's happening when the grace notes are the ame pitch too, but it's harder to hear the difference.
In reply to Can you try again? Seems a… by Marc Sabatella
Passing on some observations related to grace notes. I had issues with a beamed grace note sequence of seven notes (Appiogatura). Thought they weren't playing but maybe just too fast. So I played with a copy of the score and slowed the tempo down to 20 bpm and deleted most notes playing simultaneously in both staves so I could hear the grace notes and the host note. Moved the grace notes down an octave plus and when I played back I observed the following. When notes without grace notes are played, the highlight sweeps left to right and the sound plays back simultaneously with the cursor highlighting the note. When the grace notes are played back the scan jumps to but appears to halt on the last grace note and then jumps to the base note and then moves past. The playback however does not occur until the sweep moves in small increments as it plays back but it is already past the host note. Playback does not occur as the highlight passes over the grace notes or the host note. Not sure about the synchronization then with other notes which may be on the same beat as the host note which would playback as the sweep passes over them.
In reply to I updated to version 2.3.1,… by Owlman142
Tried my sample score from above?
(Also update to 2.3.2)