No articulations or ornaments play
Attaching a very small test score, loaded with articulations and ornaments, none of which except the fermata are observed. Extracted from a larger score evidencing the same problem (in hidden staves), and studded with many more articulations and ornaments to demonstrate the problem.
Attached is my test score. Help!
That's in MS 2.1.0 871c8ce.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| FailArt.mscz | 27.94 KB |
Comments
I don't know why and how: delete the notes and insert them again.
Test with the attachment
Has it been imported?
Edit: all notes have velocity type set to user and a velocity setting of 90 (typical for MIDI import). Resetting those to default might cure the problem in one simple step (right-click one note, select all similar, reset those to values in Inspector)
In reply to Has it been imported? by Jojo-Schmitz
A long time ago I derived it from someone else's very corrupt score; that might have been imported, I don't know. I want to know what's going on. What is missing from it? I have hundreds of notes I have to fix... thanks for finding a workaround ...
In reply to A long time ago I derived it… by [DELETED] 1831606
A workaround?
Apparently, it works by exporting your file (at least with your selection) in the XML format.
See: FailArt_0.xml
Ornaments are played (the Time stretch of fermata is not preserved, but it's not a big deal to put it back, ie: FailArt_1.mscz )
In reply to A workaround?… by cadiz1
The real file is quite complicated; I am not eager to find out what other subtle changes will be wrought by export-import through Music XML; you've already found one (the fermata). I'd like to know what's going on, thanks.
In reply to The real file is quite… by [DELETED] 1831606
You do not risk anything to try.
Another "magic" solution, I do not know, because this case can not be reproduced with a new score (from scratch), at least from what I see right now.
In reply to You do not risk anything to… by cadiz1
Well, using Shoichi's "cure", I have already fixed 10 out of the 50 measures of the piece. In an hour or two, or three, it will all be fixed. It does seem to have to do, as Jojo suggested, with the ancient ancestry of the score....(No, there is risk to try, because if I import the MuseXML and conclude, "well, it seems right", and put more work into it, and later find a subtle problem, that work might be lost). Thanks, though, I will keep this "cure" in mind should I be in this situation again.
In reply to Has it been imported? by Jojo-Schmitz
Nope -- resetting such a note to "0 Offset" velocity doesn't make it any more willing to take on ornaments or articulations (you can try my score in the thread). But it certainly had velocity 90,
In reply to Hah! Too late! I should… by [DELETED] 1831606
Change instrument, to the same it is, to reset it's properties to those from our instruments.xml , yet another known issue with imported files
In reply to Change instrument, to the… by Jojo-Schmitz
Nope. In my test file as posted, I changed the second staff to Oboe (with Staff Properties) and the ornaments still do not play. Is that not what you said? Try it.
Total success here, with Shoichi's technique. Whatever the problem is, others may have such scores with old notes imported in the distant past that will suffer this same problem, so it'd be nice to know what it was.
At any rate, here's the result: https://musescore.com/user/1831606/scores/4728651#comment-4867092 . Read the comment -- there are portato phrasings all over the place in every measure, with gateTime hacked in the .mscx to 95; the score is fully phrased, in both the YouTube (Hauptwerk) and MuseScore Audio renditions.