Copying and inserting measures
Please could the ability to copy and insert measures be created? i.e. not have to allocate a certain number of bars in advance of the copy. Soo important.
Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.
Comments
In a way I can agree with you, because that's how a word processor works. But a word processor doesn't have multiple staves like a symphony orchestra - and I don't want the default copy-and-paste Insert to open up a random number of blank measures in every stave.
For the the Append operation (where you want to paste in a number of measures at the end of the piece), the paste operation already adds any required extra measures at the end if you paste into an empty final measure.
The simple workaround is to append a chosen number of measures before you even start to enter any notes. Perhaps 100 or 200 measures at the end of your score? And if you need to open up some space in the middle of the score, the Insert key (repeated n times) can help.
In reply to In a way I can agree with… by DanielR
Thanks. I don't fully understand your concerns. In the sort of score I'm talking about, I just need to insert my copied measures, whether it creates blank measures or not. (Not interested in the Appending side of things).
This simple facility would save me oodles of time.
In reply to Thanks. I don't fully… by Ali Wood
Look at it this way. When you copy 5 measures, only your clipboard knows that you have indeed copied 5 measures. MuseScore has no idea how many measures you have copied. Or what you want to do with them. There is no connection between MuseScore and the clipboard, to speak of. So you need to tell MuseScore how many measures you have copied with the insert measures tool.
In any event, you would have to tell MuseScore whether you are pasting or inserting. As it is, it's just an extra step to set how many measures you are inserting.
In reply to Look at it this way. When… by bobjp
That's like saying that Microsoft Word has no idea how many words you have copied, or Microsoft Excel how many cells or rows. And the instruction to Insert the copied rows would just be using a 3 way toggle (Insert / Overwrite / Append).
In reply to That's like saying that… by Ali Wood
I don't think Word cares how many words you copy. Notation is more complicated. It has to deal with many different things. What if I only wanted to insert one measure and part of another?
Although, for me, the word "append" is a slightly odd term to use under the heading of "Add".
Don't get me wrong. What you suggest could be useful.
But then my viewpoint is from the perspective of someone who used to compose orchestra scores by hand. I had to be right the first time. Anything software does is a miracle to me.
In reply to In a way I can agree with… by DanielR
the last post is quite a long time ago - but I still have big problems just shifting a part of my piece to another place. It is obviously NOT so that I just can insert some MEASURES and cut and paste my music to this location. It is just the music without the measure structure that is copied. (?) I have quite a complex score with a lot of different time signatures and all this information gets lost if i just copy and paste the measures. So I repeat the question: Is there a possibility to copy a complete part of a score and paste it at another place?
In reply to the last post is quite a… by sguertler
Still not: https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/issues/15590
In reply to . by cadiz1
Is this issue in github the best place to discuss that now?
In reply to Is this issue in github the… by sguertler
It is the place to monitor.
To me what is missing here is a way to deal with the less complete copy-and-paste-insert action.
If I only copied half a measure, or 4,75 measures but only from 2 of the 5 staves. Can we define a useful flow that would reach consensus in such cases too?
In reply to To me what is missing here… by jeetee
Yes, the partial measure copy problem occurred to me, too.
In reply to Yes, the partial measure… by bobjp
I'd do this:
A. [PARTIAL 4.75 bars from SOME instruments]
4.75 bars from only some instruments? It is not a whole number of bars so refuse!.
B. [PARTIAL 4.75 bars from ALL instruments]
Same with ALL instruments? Accept the insert.
C. [WHOLE 5 bars from ALL instruments]
All instruments for a 5 bar range (30 in all)? Accept and insert all of them.
D. [WHOLE 5 bars from SOME instruments]
5 bars from just some instruments? Copy the selected instruments' 5 bars and insert blanks for the rest.
In reply to I'd do this: 1) If you chose… by Ali Wood
More difficult scenario E. 5 whole bars from a single instrument being "insert-pasted" into the same instrument.
What should happen on all other instruments?
In reply to More difficult scenario E. 5… by jeetee
It's the same principle as D. Just copy the range of instruments you have copied.
In reply to It's the same principle as D… by Ali Wood
And then I have to cut and paste all the existing notation on the other staves back into their place, because those were already completed?
In reply to And then I have to cut and… by jeetee
Don't understand, sorry. You've selected just a single instrument to copy and paste. Why would it assume that you wanted the other instruments too? Maybe I misunderstand. But it is exactly what happens when you reserve space beforehand. All that is happening is that the system reserves those bars automatically instead of you doing it manually in advance.
In reply to Don't understand, sorry. You… by Ali Wood
The question is that the insert operation might mean only insert for the current instrument. Just another valid use case that has been requested as well.
Hi Ali, this already exists.
1. Insert ONE new bar/measure (if that is all you need, you can insert as many as you need)
2. Now copy the bars/measures you want to duplicate and paste them where you want them in the new bars
Barry A
In reply to Hi Ali, this already exists… by Barry Austin
Barry,
If you read the thread in full you'll realise the whole point of this is to eliminate the need to create the empty bars first :)
I agree with this being important: a select and copy/cut/delete equivalent to the Sibelius Ctrl-select.
Does this count as a request? If not, please enlighten me.
In reply to I agree with this being… by Krak
I'm pretty sure this does not count as a request.
In reply to I agree with this being… by Krak
"Does this count as a request? If not, please enlighten me."
No. The formal process requires you to:
a) create (or already have) an account on Github - it's free BTW
b) create a New Issue on Github, of type "Feature Request"
c) fill out the Feature Request in detail, so that developers can understand exactly what is needed
Link to Github: https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/issues