Creating a quaver rest in Rachmaninoff transposition

• Dec 25, 2022 - 08:07

Hi - new to MS amd trying to produce a transposition of Rachmaninoff's vocalise for piano / violin.

If you look at the 2 pics - first is the public domain c# minor copy I am working from.
And then mine is in E minor.
I cannot see how to create that quaver rest at the start of the measure in the original
The C# at the start of the measure with the diagonal line, is from the left hand stave moved up a system (hence the 2 part voicing on the left hand and the subsequent rests which are faded out)

Should there not be a quaver rest before the RH e minor triads at the start of the measure as in the orginal.
Thanks for any help.
What an incredible application. Beautiful output.
Jonathan

Attachment Size
Original.png 176.55 KB
My arrangement.png 27.76 KB

Comments

"Should there not be a quaver rest before the RH e minor triads at the start of the measure as in the orginal."

Yes, and I show the steps which I used to get this result:
Voices.jpg

This provides a layout which is almost identical to the Public Domain score.

Attachment Size
Voices.mscz 13.43 KB

In reply to by DanielR

Wow thank you so much for this.
I am going to take a proper look tomorrow when back in the studio.
I'm brand new to Musescore so really appreciate your help.
So in your example you have put the A# in the RH clef (I was putting it in the LH and then moving it up a system) - just wondering why that is Voice 4 and not Voice 3 - or is that immaterial?
Thanks
Jonathan

In reply to by soundsvisual

"So in your example you have put the A# in the RH clef (I was putting it in the LH and then moving it up a system)"
Because the A# has to be played by the right hand, I think it makes more sense to notate it in the RH treble clef.

"... just wondering why that [A#] is Voice 4 and not Voice 3 - or is that immaterial?"
Voices 1 and 3 are almost always stem-up, and Voices 2 and 4 are stem-down. So ideally I would use Voice 4 for this A#, because stem-down is the default stem direction.

Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.