MusicXML import of ornaments (trills, mordents, turns) with accidental-mark doesn't work

• Jan 2, 2023 - 19:32
Reported version
3.6
Type
Functional
Frequency
Once
Severity
S3 - Major
Reproducibility
Always
Status
active
Regression
No
Workaround
No
Project
MuseScore

Open the attached MusicXML file, which has several trills, most of which have an accidental-mark element which should place an accidental above the trill. The MusicXML file also has text directions next to each trill, saying whether the intention is "whole" step up or "half" step up, so someone looking at MuseScore's rendering of the file can determine whether the rendered accidentals are correct.

Note that MuseScore does not render any accidentals on the trills at all.

MuseScore 4.0 and MuseScore 3 both have this bug.

Attachment Size
trillaccid.musicxml 6.63 KB

Comments

• Jan 2, 2023 - 20:55
Frequency Once ⇒ Many

For the record, while this MusicXML file was originally written using music21, I modified it by hand to add all the accidental-mark elements, as I thought they should be written. I have written an issue against music21 (which I intend to implement myself) to import/export ornament accidental-mark elements properly from/to MusicXML.

Reply