Note-breaking problem, again (3.3RC)
OS: macOS 10.15, Arch.: x86_64, MuseScore version (64-bit): 3.3.0.23833, revision: d3bff12
I'm not making this up, nor is it "random variation in note intensity". In m 7 the red G# in the soprano gets played as two quarter notes, with a very distinct, deep, unmistakable break between them. The Soprano and Alto are soloed; if the alto is silenced, it doesn't fail. I deleted the note and re-created it. No improvement.
The score was first created in MS2.
See if you can duplicate this (enclosed).
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| JDP_from_HReisse.mscz | 23.27 KB |
Comments
I've listened with normal Aah-patches because the expressive-patches never play (not sounding) on my system.
I think there is nothing wrong, everything is as it should be.
I exported it as mp3 format (3 measures: 6-8).
In reply to I've listened with normal… by Ziya Mete Demircan
OK, thanks, this helps; I wonder why I suffer it..... Anybody else want to waste 5 minutes for me?
Sounds perfectly normal to me using the default soundfont.
In reply to Sounds perfectly normal to… by Marc Sabatella
Thanks for trying ,,,, no, this is not Gaslight, this is really happening to me,,,
In reply to Thanks for trying ,,,, no,… by [DELETED] 1831606
Do you still hear it in an MP3 if you export? If not, can you record an MP3 just capturing the computer audio, or even using the mic to record the speakers? Then post the M
In reply to Do you still hear it in an… by Marc Sabatella
I will try MP3. I don't think there's a way to record while it's playing (or you could steal copyrighted content!).
In reply to I will try MP3. I don't… by [DELETED] 1831606
Absolutely generated the error to the MP3 (attached).
In reply to Absolutely generated the… by [DELETED] 1831606
While we're here, why were my solo selections of the soprano and alto ignored by the MP3 writer? Are all solos and mutes ignored? This could be a very large problem for making sectional audios ....
In reply to While we're here, why were… by [DELETED] 1831606
Not sure, I've never tried exporting solo settings, but could easily believe it's a deliberate feature that solo is not honored for export but mute is. In any case, that does seem to be what is happening.
In reply to Not sure, I've never tried… by Marc Sabatella
OK, Mute is. that's consistent with my experience. Let metry that ...
In reply to I will try MP3. I don't… by [DELETED] 1831606
Sorry, your MP3 sounds fine to me. I hear the other voices drop out, but the soprano never wavers. Verified this with Audacity too.
BTW, Apple may or may not provide a built in way to record the computer audio, but Audacity or any other audio program surely can.
In reply to Sorry, your MP# sounds fone… by Marc Sabatella
At M 7 there!??
In reply to At M 7 there!?? by [DELETED] 1831606
Yes, 42 seconds in.
In reply to Yes, 42 seconds in. by Marc Sabatella
I made a properly-muted MP3, and listened to both very carefully, and now I'm not sure any more; I trust you both and Audacity, and thanks again for spending the time. It must be an auditory illusion, a "Yanny vs. Laurel" unique to my aging ears .... thanks both again, anyway.
In reply to Sorry, your MP# sounds fone… by Marc Sabatella
Audacity can't do that on the Mac -- you need special 3rd party loop-back programs to make it possible.
In reply to Audacity can't do that on… by [DELETED] 1831606
Maybe not recording the audio directly, but surely the microphone wasn't hacked to not pick up the speakers?
EDIT: and I will stop calling you "surely"
In reply to Maybe not recording the… by Marc Sabatella
perhaps ....
In reply to Maybe not recording the… by Marc Sabatella
I've never heard of "Surely the Microphone"....