Weird behaviour if combining different notes with ties in github-musescore-musescore-6c735b8

• Oct 20, 2017 - 15:46

Weird behaviour of a score if using ties: Please open the attached score with 6c735b8. Select all notes and draw a tie with "+". Then a lot of lines is drawn between almost all notes of the score.

I expect tying will be rejected because not all notes have the same pitch.

On the other hand, drawing a slur on the other hand (with "s") runs well.

Bug or feature?

Attachment Size
Unbenannt.mscz 3.82 KB

Comments

A new misunderstanding (and not a bug, same thing in 2.1)

"I expect tying will be rejected because not all notes have the same pitch."
Contrary to what you write, except the last C, all the other notes (quarter notes) have the same pitch in the last measure (32th)

So, take the time to re-read the handbook if necessary: https://musescore.org/en/handbook/ties. You can see: "Ties are normally created between adjacent notes in the same voice, but MuseScore also supports ties between non-adjacent notes and between notes in different voices."

In reply to by cadiz1

So I learned:
Beside adjacent notes, ties can be built between notes with same pitch, but the endpoint (or startpoint) may be located in different measures, even in different voices.

This seems to be the reason for the horizontally stacked ties. Is my opinion correct?

Thank you and kind regards

Joachim Backes

Do you still have an unanswered question? Please log in first to post your question.