Loop playback does not work correctly
When I try to play bars 13-16 on loop, Musescore plays bars 9-12 instead.
The obvious possible remedies (remove loop makers and redefining them, close & restart) do not work.
Update: there seems to be some offset: if I choose bars 21-24 for replay, MS plays bars 13-16.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Jaya Shiva Shankarah.mscz | 31.46 KB |
Comments
You mean repeat bars, not loop markers, right?
Why have P1, P2, etc. been entered as a chord symbols?
In reply to You mean repeat bars, not… by Jojo-Schmitz
I am talking about loop markers. P1 etc just indicate the parts - I have changed them to text now - but that does not change anything.
In reply to I am talking about loop… by Dick_Veldkamp
Confirmed. Strange...
That P1 etc. being chord symbols is unrelated, but just wrong
In reply to The repeats don't play back… by Jojo-Schmitz
As I wrote originally, I have marked measures 13-16 for loop replay.
P1 etc: has been corrected to text.
BTW Thanks for answering so quickly. ;-)
In reply to As I wrote originally, I… by Dick_Veldkamp
? I thought 21-24, with 13-16 being played then?
In reply to ? I thought 21-24, with 13… by Jojo-Schmitz
That was the "fix" I found. But of course you don't want an offset in the measure count,
BTW When I play normally, all repeats are handled correctly.
In reply to As I wrote originally, I… by Dick_Veldkamp
Ah: play bars 13-16 on loop, Musescore plays bars 9-12 instead
Both confirmed
Might be https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/issues/16069
But more likely it is https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/issues/12972
So set tempo to 120 ;-)
In reply to Ah: 21-24 for replay, MS… by Jojo-Schmitz
I set the tempo to 120 (at the top of the score), but no change, bug is still there.
In reply to I set the tempo to 120 (at… by Dick_Veldkamp
Hmm, here too, not sure what I saw earlier
I have duplicated this looping issue. The problem occurs when there is a repeat barline prior to the beginning of the loop. 1st/2nd endings do not affect the issue.
In my instance, when a repeat barline is present, the playback of the loop consistently starts at 19 measures prior to the actual start of the loop setting, regardless where i locate the loop (after the repeat). When I remove the repeat barline, the loop plays correctly.
In reply to I have duplicated this… by Jacksonian
For me, this only happens when there is a repeat prior to the beginning of the loop and "play repeats" is checked in the playback settings drop down (the gear icon in the toolbar). It works correctly if I uncheck that.
In reply to For me, this only happens… by Postman
This workaround worked for me. Thank you for sharing.
In reply to For me, this only happens… by Postman
This worked perfectly. Thanks.
The bug definitely has to do with repeats.
I have discovered this same bug. That is loop playback after some repeated measures do not loop in the correct location. Is there a fix yet?
Thanks
Loop playback does not work at all since I installed Musescore 4. I select the desired part of the music, and the arrows appear at the start and the end, but when I hit Play, the selection only plays once, without repeating. It used to work fine in Musescore 3, but there must be a glitch in the new version.
When selecting the first bar and applying Looping, an error appears in the sound. A type of delay at the start of the measure.
I have this problem too. To uncheck "Play Repeats" really work, but it strange. I need always turn off/on this function for current goals. Hope the developers will fix this problem.
This is happening for me in version 4.2.1. Unchecking 'play repeats' does seem to work for me.
Hi, I also got mad at this bug !
The best hack I found is to check/uncheck the 'Play Repeats' option in the 'Playback Settings' (drop down gear icon in the toolbar).
If you just want to listen to the loop of your selection, uncheck 'Play Repeats'.
But if you want to play the part as it is supposed to be read (for example, if you want to export it as an audio file), check 'Play Repeats'.
Hope it makes sense and helps...
In reply to Hi, I also got mad at this… by brunofievet5
Funny thing is that the first set of repeats works fine in my rudimentary piece but on the next page is a second set of repeats that are ignored during playback no matter what I do. I started using MuseScore as an arranging tool so this would be useful if I could get it working. The version is 4.3.2.
Anyone else see this?
In reply to Funny thing is that the… by boosifier
Ok, my bad. When I was troubleshooting a volta issue I must have set the last bar to Play Count = 1. Now it repeats correctly.
In reply to Ok, my bad. When I was… by boosifier
has the loop marker issue been resolved? It's still not playing in between the loop markers when the are repeat signs present before the desired loop section.
In reply to has the loop marker issue… by richsalvante
The above mentioned https://github.com/musescore/MuseScore/issues/12972 is still open
In reply to The above mentioned https:/… by Jojo-Schmitz
Thanks. I just unchecked "play repeats" and it works.